Enable JavaScript to run this app.
Skip to main content
OpenTable logo
  1. Home
  2. United States
  3. New York State

Best American Restaurants in Bay Shore

Price
Regions
Areas
Top Rated
Dining Options
Seating options
Accessibility

34 restaurants available nearby

A photo of Salt and Barrel restaurant
1. Salt and Barrel
4.7
Exceptional(1674)
Price: Expensive
• American • Bay Shore
Booked 30 times today
An authentic oyster bar with an urban vibe and vintage soul. Serving classic cocktails, craft taps, and coastal fare with a rotating selection of east/west coast oysters daily.
A photo of Roadtrip restaurant
2. Roadtrip
4.6
Exceptional(68)
Price: Expensive
• American • Bay Shore
Booked 26 times today
Come to Roadtrip Restaurant, where we celebrate American cuisine and cocktails. Join us on a culinary journey through America's favorite states and flavors! Savor our delicious BBQ, smoked on-site, or indulge in a USDA Prime Beef Center Cut Filet Mignon with purple potato purée. Chef Mike Artist continues his quest to earn a Michelin star, bringing his passion to every dish. Enjoy exceptional American cuisine in our modern, classy Americana setting, featuring just the right amount of wood accents for a touch of rustic charm.
A photo of ITA Kitchen restaurant
3. ITA Kitchen
4.3
Awesome(948)
Price: Expensive
• American • Bay Shore
Booked 31 times today
Experience the true essence of American cuisine at ITA Kitchen in the heart of Bay Shore's quaint village. Renowned for its innovative approach to Italian-American dishes, ITA Kitchen consistently impresses with its "outstanding" food and "wonderful" service, as noted by numerous glowing reviews. Guests rave about the authenticity and quality, highlighting dishes like the "phenomenal" meatballs and the "divine" Rainbow Cookie Martini. The vibrant atmosphere, coupled with the friendly and attentive staff, ensures every meal is memorable. As one diner put it, ITA Kitchen is "by far the best Italian restaurant on Long Island!!!!" making it a must-visit for anyone seeking a top-notch dining experience.
A photo of Butera's Restaurant of Bay Shore restaurant
4. Butera's Restaurant of Bay Shore
4.5
Awesome(971)
Price: Moderate
• American • Bay Shore
Booked 27 times today
Butera's Restaurant of Bay Shore is a beacon of American cuisine in Bay Shore, renowned for its commitment to quality and authenticity. This spot dazzles diners with its rustic yet modern American offerings, creatively prepared with locally sourced ingredients. Patrons rave about their culinary experience, highlighting dishes like the "out of this world" pork chop and the "always delicious" double cut pork chop, which have become fan favorites. The atmosphere is equally praised, with live music and an industrial chic decor that adds an extra layer of delight. Reviewers consistently mention the "excellent service" and the warm welcome from staff, making Butera's a must-visit for a truly memorable American dining experience.
A photo of The Linwood Restaurant and Cocktails restaurant
5. The Linwood Restaurant and Cocktails
4.8
Exceptional(805)
Price: Moderate
• American • Bay Shore
Booked 29 times today
The Linwood Restaurant and Cocktails, located in the vibrant neighborhood of Bay Shore, is celebrated for its exceptional American Gastropub offerings and an array of thoughtfully crafted cocktails. Patrons rave about the "unbelievable food" and the atmosphere where "every meal is even better than the last." The restaurant stands out for its variety of dishes, including favorites like the "grilled octopus that is to die for" and a "fantastic" meatloaf. The ambiance is described as having a "cool vibe" with velvet seats, creating an inviting space for diners. With glowing reviews for both food and service, The Linwood promises an excellent gastro pub experience where quality and creativity shine. Whether it's a lively night out or a special occasion, The Linwood is a top choice for unforgettable dining in Bay Shore.
A photo of King's Chop House restaurant
6. King's Chop House
4.8
Exceptional(195)
Price: Very Expensive
• American • Bay Shore
Booked 8 times today
Contemporary American Steakhouse featuring Prime Dry Aged Beef, Classic Cocktails and an exceptional wine list.
A photo of The Lakehouse restaurant
7. The Lakehouse
4.7
Exceptional(3162)
Price: Expensive
• American • Bay Shore
Booked 41 times today
The Lakehouse in Bay Shore, NY, is a contemporary American dining gem that consistently delights its patrons. Celebrated for its "always delicious" meals and exceptional service, this dockside treasure offers more than just a meal; it provides an experience. With its stunning waterfront views and cozy ambiance complemented by multiple fireplaces, it's no wonder reviewers rave about the quality and creativity of the dishes. Favorites like the "sensational" baked oysters and "magnificent" truffle risotto showcase the authentic and expertly crafted menu. Additionally, the ability to arrive by boat adds a unique touch to the dining experience, making The Lakehouse a must-visit for those seeking a truly remarkable Contemporary American meal.
A photo of Captain Bill's restaurant
8. Captain Bill's
4.7
Exceptional(2025)
Price: Expensive
• American • Bay Shore
Booked 22 times today
At Captain Bill's in Bay Shore, the essence of American cuisine is celebrated with flair and finesse. Renowned for its waterfront charm and a menu that showcases the best of local seafood and prime aged steaks, Captain Bill's represents American dining at its finest. Guests rave about the "delicious and fresh seafood" and "perfectly seasoned prime rib," highlighting the restaurant's commitment to quality and authenticity. The ambiance, described as "beautiful and kind of romantic," complements the excellent service, ensuring a memorable dining experience. Whether it's enjoying a sunset over the Great South Bay or indulging in a Sunday brunch buffet with unlimited Bloody Marys and Mimosas, Captain Bill's is a culinary gem that consistently impresses, making it a must-visit destination for lovers of genuine American cuisine.
A photo of Whalers restaurant
9. Whalers
4.7
Exceptional(1350)
Price: Expensive
• American • Bay Shore
Booked 4 times today
Nestled in the heart of Bay Shore, Whalers offers a unique twist on Contemporary American cuisine that consistently impresses its patrons. Reviewers rave about their innovative dishes, such as the "lobster roll" and "seafood risotto," which are both described as "fantastic" and "fabulous." The restaurant's setting with "huge windows and views of the Great South Bay" complements its culinary delights, making it a popular choice for both casual diners and special events. The consistent high praise for their service and atmosphere, with comments like "service was excellent all three visits!" and "beautiful views and great service," highlights their commitment to providing a stellar dining experience. Whalers is not just a meal; it's a celebration of modern American flavors and heartfelt hospitality in a stunning waterfront location.
A photo of The James restaurant
10. The James
4.5
Awesome(306)
Price: Very Expensive
• American • Babylon
Booked 73 times today
The James in Babylon is a beacon of exceptional American cuisine, where each dish is a testament to quality and creativity. Patrons rave about the "beyond amazing" food, highlighting dishes like the "melt-in-your-mouth Wagyu tomahawk" and "very, very good" seafood, reflecting the restaurant’s commitment to using the finest and freshest local ingredients. The atmosphere is praised as "absolutely stunning," with a decor that seamlessly blends elegance with comfort. The service at The James matches the high quality of its dishes, with guests noting the staff is "fantastic" and "knowledgeable," making every dining experience memorable. As a venue that transforms dining into an experience, The James stands out for its excellent American fare, making it a must-visit in Babylon.

How is content generated

See what locals rave about

From verified diners like you
From verified diners like you
  • patriciaVIP
    New York City •3 reviews
    5.0
    Dined 4 days ago
    Awesome dining experience with the family for Christmas Eve. 10/10 recommend
    More info
    ITA KitchenPrice: Expensive• Italian• Bay Shore
    •
    4.3
  • juliannVIP
    Orange County •3 reviews
    5.0
    Dined 5 days ago
    Roadtrip is a unique experience offering a variety of delicious menu options representing the USA. All ingredients, even the alcoholic beverages are made in the USA. Phil, the owner, is very attentive to every detail. I personally love the weekly change of menu, creative and delicious! Bottom line, food, drinks and service are great! Best burgers and soups too!
    More info
    RoadtripPrice: Expensive• American• Bay Shore
    •
    4.6
  • Anthony
    New York City •20 reviews
    5.0
    Dined 7 days ago
    Great food and value nice place , only drawbacks parking lots especially on weekends. Worth the parking hassle. Very nice in nice weather they open large doors.
    More info
    Butera's Restaurant of Bay ShorePrice: Moderate• Italian• Bay Shore
    •
    4.5
  • KRISTOFERVIP
    New York City •20 reviews
    5.0
    Dined on 20 Dec 2024
    Salt & Barrell is a combination of great food and great service with an energetic vibe. Whether it's the host, the manager or the server, everyone who works there is super friendly, and very accommodating. The menu evolves, so going regularly doesn't create monotony. The drinks are phenomenal, and their whiskey menu (The Bible) is extensive. They could use a little improvement on the wine list (which is very small, with not a lot of good options), but you can easily get past this. Salt & Barrell is by far one of the best restaurants in Bay Shore, and worth a visit.
    More info
    Salt and BarrelPrice: Expensive• Contemporary American• Bay Shore
    •
    4.7
  • AshleyVIP
    New York City •13 reviews
    5.0
    Dined on 18 Dec 2024
    One of my favorite spots! The food is always great. Loved the grilled octopus appetizer, one of the best octopus dishes I’ve had! The meatloaf is so delicious and the fried chicken sandwich is a must! Absolutely beautiful ambiance!
    More info
    The Linwood Restaurant and CocktailsPrice: Moderate• Contemporary American• Bay Shore
    •
    4.8

Discover best American restaurants in Bay Shore

Discover the best of American cuisine in the bustling area of Bay Shore, Suffolk, New York. This locality boasts a diverse selection of American dining options, from classic American fare to innovative dishes that highlight local ingredients. Bay Shore's dining scene is characterized by its vibrant atmosphere and commitment to culinary excellence, making it a prime destination for food enthusiasts. Whether you're in the mood for seafood, steak, or a fusion of Italian-American flavors, the restaurants in Bay Shore cater to every palate with their high-quality, creatively crafted dishes. Patrons consistently praise the exceptional service, scenic locations, and the welcoming ambiance that these eateries offer. Each restaurant in this area ensures a memorable dining experience, emphasizing freshness, flavor, and impeccable service. Explore Bay Shore for a true taste of American cuisine that combines traditional cooking with modern twists.

Explore OpenTable

Discover
OpenTable
  • About Us
  • Blog
  • Careers
  • Press
More
Our sites
Businesses
  • Delight more diners
  • Restaurant Blog
Join us on
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Impressum
  • Cookies and Interest-Based Ads
  • Cookie Preferences
Copyright © 2024 OpenTable International Ltd. Alphabeta Building, 14-18 Finsbury Square, London EC2A 1AH - All rights reserved.
OpenTable is part of Booking Holdings, the world leader in online travel and related services.
Booking Logo
Priceline Logo
KAYAK Logo
Agoda Logo
OpenTable Logo