Best American Restaurants in Gates Mills

A perfect way to celebrate a 97th birthday! Let’s begin with the menu, presented to us when we were seated. It was printed with an elegant welcoming greeting: “Happy Birthday, Lorry!” Rose, our server, guided us through the menu options. For starters, the fresh oysters were bright and perfectly presented, and the Caesar salads crisp with perfectly balanced citrus salt and richness. We ordered the Parker rolls and then another order. They are that good! For our entrees, the seared salmon was perfectly seasoned and fresh, the lobster tail generous and tender, and the tuna teriyaki seared and very fresh. The soba noodles were the perfect complement. As it was a birthday, a complementary carrot cake arrived with a candle, and we supplemented it with additional desserts from the menu: a fabulous cheesecake and caramel bread pudding. We were the last to leave and never felt rushed. The staff, in succession, wished us a wonderful evening. Well, the staff ensured us that it was a wonderful evening. With gratitude to all.

Sarah was a great waitress. We will be asking for her at our next visit.

Austin's always has terrific steaks and this meal was no exception!

Had a great dinner with a couple friends - delish food and the staff was all excellent & friendly. The ambiance was wonderful - cozy and well laid out. The right balance of feeling like you're somewhere fun and hip, but also could have private conversation - highly recommend!

The food was amazing! And the quiet ambiance enhanced the experience. The only disappointment was the coffee at the end. I would have expected a much smoother and less bitter choice by the restaurant.