Best American Restaurants in Midtown

This is Jo, Paul's wife. Ended up one for dinner. Did the prefix menu with pork and the drink pairings. All of the food, and I mean everything, was delightful; unexpected complex flavors. The drink pairings were somewhat unconventional well suited. My only, dislike, was the desert wine, as it was a bit too sweet for my taste. Not sure how many others request, but it might be nice to have coffee or espresso available after the meal. The atmosphere is sparing; focus on the food and your dinner mates. Music was nice, but a tad too loud. I plan on bringing at least one "foodie", friend to Nonesuch. I don't consider myself a food snob or as having a very developed palate, however, I'm far enough along to be able to appreciate different, multifaceted, flavors. We eat with our ears, eyes, and noses, as well as our mouths. If you are looking to, "get your fill of grub in under 45 minutes", this may not be the place for you. If you like, "delightfully different", I can heartily recommend this place. My visit was most satisfactory. I know I'll be back!

Food was quite good. We had duck, chicken and steak. Steak was perfectly cooked, but not as flavorful as we expected. Asparagus and cauliflower were unexpectedly good. Rachel, our server was very good. Room was quite quiet unlike many of the other places we dine. We will return.

We had a wonderful dinner out at Tellers last night for my wife’s birthday. It was decorated for the holidays & was very impressive. Our server was very sweet and very attentive. She offered great suggestions as well as told us the history of the building. We had the bread, the fried artichoke appetizer, the short rib rigatoni, and the lobster ravioli. All were flavorful and delicious. We also enjoyed the Brandy Alexander and the the Voodoo Ranger Juice Force IPA. We stayed at the upstairs hotel which was equally nice. Highly recommend!

Excellent, tasty and unique selection of margaritas and cocktails.

Very pub atmosphere (at least downstairs; we didn't look upstairs), so kind of cramped and chaotic. But certainly has its charm, and the food was very good. I had the stroganoff and my husband had a burger, and we split a pretzel. I would go again under the right circumstances.