Best American Restaurants in New Market

Fantastic experience. We sat in the bar area. We had excellent service. We enjoyed great drinks and a great burger. We were able to sit and enjoy our visit and didn’t feel rushed. Will be back soon!

Great dining experience. The ambiance is fun. The building was a Catholic girls school with a long history. Closed awhile ago and has been resurrected as a top notch restaurant. My wife and I both noted the great job done to keep some of the impressive architecture and icons while modernizing the overall look. We sat in the mezzanine (choir) and had a phenomenal view of the place. We started with cocktails and were very impressed with the offering. I had a gin based drink flavored with barsol pisco and raspberry, while my wife had a bourbon, rum, honey, and grapefruit flavored drink. We'd recommend both. Food was top notched and rather innovative. We started with a chicken liver pate that was then fried and served with an onion jam and waffles. Highly recommend. Entrees were short ribs for my wife and prime rib for myself. Both done perfectly. Sides are separate (ala carte). We had mac-n-cheese which was top notch as well as broccoli which was paired with pesto, absolutely worth trying. Service was prompt, professional, and engaging. Our waiter Ben was the quintessential professional. They have a sommelier, Steve, who was able to recommend an Oregon pinot noir that paired very well. Only watch out is the outing will be pricy. Special occasions seem to be the vibe. Overall, top notch. We will be back as the experience was gratifying.

Our server, Chad, served us very attentively, and our food was delicious! It was an excellent place to celebrate my wife’s birthday, and we will plan to come back!

We love this place - always a wonderful meal, service and atmosphere, so it was a given that we dine here to celebrate my parent’s 56th anniversary and my 49th birthday. Last night did not disappoint! Yogi was a wonderful, friendly, attentive server. He ensured that our drinks were always filled and that our food was exactly how we ordered it. Everyone was very happy with their meals (steaks cooked to order, burgers, cilantro grilled chicken) and the philly cheese steak egg rolls and warm carrot cake were to die for! And if that wasn’t enough, Yogi surprised my parents and me with creme brulee cheesecakes and sweet anniversary and birthday cards signed by the staff. We needed to be rolled out of there; we ate way too much but it was all so, so good. We will definitely be back very soon!

Great Italian food, one of the best in Frederick. The decor needs work. Excellent service, very friendly!