Best American Restaurants in Gilgo

43 restaurants available nearby

1. The James

4.5

Price: Very Expensive

• American • Babylon

Booked 59 times today

The James in Babylon is a beacon of exceptional American cuisine, where each dish is a testament to quality and creativity. Patrons rave about the "beyond amazing" food, highlighting dishes like the "melt-in-your-mouth Wagyu tomahawk" and "very, very good" seafood, reflecting the restaurant’s commitment to using the finest and freshest local ingredients. The atmosphere is praised as "absolutely stunning," with a decor that seamlessly blends elegance with comfort. The service at The James matches the high quality of its dishes, with guests noting the staff is "fantastic" and "knowledgeable," making every dining experience memorable. As a venue that transforms dining into an experience, The James stands out for its excellent American fare, making it a must-visit in Babylon.

A photo of Mercato Kitchen & Cocktails restaurant

2. Mercato Kitchen & Cocktails

4.8

Exceptional(812)

Price: Expensive

• American • Massapequa

Booked 17 times today

Mercato Kitchen & Cocktails, nestled in the charming neighborhood of Massapequa Park, exemplifies the epitome of Bistro cuisine with its delightful blend of American and Italian flavors. Praised for its "always great food no matter how often we go," Mercato captures the essence of a traditional market, or 'mercato,' offering freshness and quality in every dish. From the beloved buffalo eggrolls to the exquisite crab crusted halibut, each meal is a testament to the culinary skills of Executive Chef Matt and his team. Patrons rave about the "welcoming atmosphere" and "exceptional service," making it a must-visit for anyone craving an authentic Bistro experience. Whether it's for a casual meal or a special occasion, Mercato promises a memorable dining experience with its "fabulous place for casual dining or even more elaborate dishes."

3. Big Daddy's

4.6

Exceptional(485)

Price: Moderate

• American • Massapequa

Booked 3 times today

Big Daddy’s in Massapequa, NY, is a beacon of authentic Cajun cuisine, capturing the vibrant flavors and spirited culture of New Orleans. Since 1993, this restaurant has been lauded for its "spectacular" dishes, such as the Pasta Jumbalaya and Blackened Gator, both praised for their bold and authentic flavors. Diners consistently rave about the "great Cajun classics" and the ambiance that makes every visit memorable. The lively atmosphere is complemented by live music, adding an extra layer of authenticity. As one reviewer puts it, Big Daddy’s is the place where "the liquor will have you seeing double but that's exactly why you'd have a hella good time!" With generous portions and a fun casual setting, Big Daddy’s is not just a meal; it’s an experience that embodies the heart and soul of Cajun cooking.

A photo of American Beauty in the Park restaurant

4. American Beauty in the Park

4.8

Exceptional(172)

Price: Expensive

• American • Massapequa

Booked 7 times today

From the hearts that brought you American Beauty Bistro in Massapequa and American Beauty Bar and Grill in Bellmore, comes the long awaited 3rd location in the heart of Massapequa Park - American Beauty in the Park. Centrally located on Park Boulevard, American Beauty in the Park brings the same charm, character and hospitality our guests have come to love, with an updated, more mature setting. Bringing with them renowned Chef Johnny "Pasta" Orphanos, to create an elevated culinary experience not offered anywhere else on the block. World Class and Rare wines will be offered to our guests, alongside Craft Cocktails for every palette. We look forward to welcoming you to the newest addition to the American Beauty Family!

A photo of Red Lobster - Copiague restaurant

5. Red Lobster - Copiague

4.3

Awesome(32)

Price: Moderate

• American • Amityville

Elevate your day at Red Lobster, where fun meets fancy and every meal is a celebration. Whether you’re marking a special occasion or treating yourself or your crew, Red Lobster is the perfect place to enjoy all your seafood favorites. Dive into our signature shrimp, wild caught lobster and crab, and more. Plus, a variety of fish and popular non-seafood items like our Cajun Chicken Linguini Alfredo. Looking for a showstopper? Create Your Own Ultimate Feast or select a Live Maine Lobster straight from the tank. Or explore our Daily Deals with a different special available each weekday at a price you’ll love. Toast the day with Signature Cocktails including Lobster Punch and Main Deck Margarita Flights to make any moment feel festive. You won’t want to miss our newest menu items or special promotions like Lobsterfest and Crabfest. Reserve online today. Group Dining, To Go, or Catering options. For parties of 11+, please call.

A photo of Besito Mexican - West Islip restaurant

6. Besito Mexican - West Islip

4.7

Exceptional(1817)

Price: Moderate

• American • West Islip

Booked 30 times today

Besito Mexican in West Islip is a gem for those craving authentic Contemporary Mexican cuisine. Praised for its "excellent" flavors by the New York Times, Besito enchants with the cozy warmth of a private hacienda. Diners revel in the fresh, table-side guacamole and an impressive selection of over 75 tequilas imported directly from Mexico. Patrons consistently laud the restaurant's culinary delights, with reviews raving about the "delicious" Arrachera and the "refreshing" El Pepino Margarita. The ambiance and attentive service only enhance the dining experience, making Besito a must-visit for lovers of refined Mexican cuisine. As one diner put it, "This was truly the best authentic Mexican food I've ever had." Besito Mexican stands out as a beacon of culinary excellence in West Islip.

7. Mito - Babylon

4.1

Excellent(84)

Price: Very Expensive

• American • Babylon

Booked 6 times today

Mito - Babylon, situated in the vibrant heart of Babylon, is a culinary gem that redefines Contemporary Asian cuisine. Renowned for its innovative approach to Japanese dishes, Mito features a menu where each creation is not only a treat for the palate but also a work of art. Patrons rave about the "unforgettable dining experiences," with favorites like the Dimsum tasting and perfectly crisp rock shrimp. The head chef, with a prestigious background from Jean Georges and Buddha Bar, ensures a high-quality dining adventure by integrating unexpected ingredients that dazzle and delight. As one diner put it, Mito offers "the best food I’ve ever eaten," underlining the restaurant's commitment to excellence and creativity in every dish. Whether it's for a casual happy hour or a special night out, Mito promises an exceptional experience in Contemporary Asian dining.

A photo of Argyle Grill & Tavern restaurant

8. Argyle Grill & Tavern

new

3.8

Excellent(5)

Price: Very Expensive

• American • Babylon

Booked 9 times today

Executive Chef: Chris WeissLocated in the heart of Babylon Village

9. Lily's Babylon

4.6

Exceptional(11)

Price: Expensive

• American • Babylon

Booked 5 times today

At Lily's Babylon in the heart of Babylon, the essence of Irish cuisine comes to life with a delectable twist on traditional fare. Known for its vibrant atmosphere and exceptional Irish dishes, Lily's stands out as a culinary gem. Patrons often rave about the "best in Long Island" onion soup and the consistently praised potato soup. Authentic Irish favorites like the Shepherd's Pie receive glowing testimonials for their quality, with one guest exclaiming about the "perfect pints of Guinness" that complement the hearty meals. A customer favorite, the short ribs, are described as "absolutely lick the plate clean delicious," highlighting the restaurant's commitment to flavor and quality. Whether it's the full plates of Irish classics or the festive ambiance, Lily's Babylon consistently delivers a truly authentic Irish dining experience that keeps guests coming back for more.

A photo of Houlihan's - Farmingdale restaurant

10. Houlihan's - Farmingdale

4.6

Exceptional(506)

Price: Moderate

• American • Farmingdale

Booked 5 times today

Since 1972, we've believed in quality ingredients, cooking from scratch and having fun. From our famous 'Shrooms and Stuffed Chicken Breast to our unique burger blend and ahi tuna, we believe in celebrating the small things and that every moment deserves a toast in its honor. So grab a drink (perhaps our signature Long Island Iced Tea), enjoy some great conversation and let us serve you an excellent meal.

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

See what locals rave about

From verified diners like you

E
Elena
New York City •16 reviews
5.0
Dined 1 day ago
Always such a nice experience- we really enjoyed the spicy Ala vodka and Di Mare - really excellent- music was great and the staff always welcoming! .
More info
Mercato Kitchen & CocktailsPrice: Expensive• Italian• Massapequa
•
4.8
H
HeatherVIP
New York City •7 reviews
5.0
Dined 3 days ago
Leslie was an exceptional server! She offered great recommendations and was really friendly.
More info
American Beauty in the ParkPrice: Expensive• American• Massapequa
•
4.8
L
LisaVIP
New York City •23 reviews
4.0
Dined 4 days ago
Really fun evening, great band that was on early 6:30-9 which is amazing since most music first begins at 8 or 9 pm. Exciting Cajun menu and interesting cocktails. I’m not a fan of this type of cuisine so was thrilled to have a delicious little gem salad with shrimp, something delicious and unsauced. The decor and floor plan can certainly use an updated style, lots of wasted space near the bar where folks could be spending their $$ on cocktails . Fun time, definitely recommend.
More info
Big Daddy'sPrice: Moderate• American• Massapequa
•
4.6
S
Scott & ChristyVIP
New York City •3 reviews
5.0
Dined 4 days ago
Another fantastic night! We went for my husband's 50th birthday and brought the kids (12,11,9) for the first time. They did opt for the children's menu and had the chicken fingers, burger, and pasta dishes. All 3 loved their food. The adults shared the seafood appetizer special and baked clams. My MIL and I had filet mignon, FIL and husband went with strip steaks.
More info
The JamesPrice: Very Expensive• Continental• Babylon
•
4.5
D
Danielle
New York City •2 reviews
5.0
Dined 7 days ago
They didn’t pack all of our food to go and didn’t realize it until I got home. Other than that, everything was amazing as always.
More info
Besito Mexican - West IslipPrice: Moderate• Mexican• West Islip
•
4.7

Explore OpenTable

Gilgo

American

Best American Restaurants in Gilgo

Price

Regions

Areas

Top Rated

Dining Options

Seating options

Accessibility

43 restaurants available nearby

1. The James

2. Mercato Kitchen & Cocktails

3. Big Daddy's

4. American Beauty in the Park

5. Red Lobster - Copiague

6. Besito Mexican - West Islip

7. Mito - Babylon

8. Argyle Grill & Tavern

9. Lily's Babylon

10. Houlihan's - Farmingdale

See what locals rave about

Explore OpenTable