Best American Restaurants in Pickerington

We were celebrating our anniversary. The ambience was inviting our server Dave was one of the best people in service I’ve encountered at a restaurant of this caliber. The food that we had which was a crabcake dinner a fried chicken dinner was very good. I would say the chicken wasn’t exactly what I expected but very good. We also tried the desserts which was a peanut butter pie and the carrot cake and I would say some of the best I’ve had in my 45 years on this earth. I would definitely go back again and I would recommend it to others. It is not cheap,but it is well worth the experience.

Pleasant, inviting, food was amazing, and wine flight was fantastic. Waitstaff were personable and informative but not pushy.

Wonderful and personal experience at Lindeys! The food was absolutely fantastic and the staff was so friendly, especially to our kiddos. We got the calamari, ahi tuna, bread, and highlight for me was the burger. The kids meal portions were also very generous! Certainly a great place to celebrate a special occasion!

Fantastic first visit two days before Valentine’s Day. Restaurant was busy! Mykl, our server, was great! The appetizer of double cut bacon was delicious. Hubby had steak medallions with garlic mashed potatoes. I had shrimp linguine with capers. Both entrees were fantastic - well seasoned with enough for multiple servings. They also have a great selection of mock tails. We look our next visit.

Our waitress was amazing! She was very attentive, made great suggestions, & went above & beyond for our birthday celebration. We recommend the eggplant parmesan, margherita pizza, arancini, and the Berry Blast cocktail. The birthday girl got a free dessert & a spiked strawberry with a huge “sparkler” lit up to commemorate the evening. This was our first time here & we will be back!