Best American Restaurants in Water Mill

10 restaurants available nearby

1. Shippy's

4.6

Exceptional(275)

Price: Moderate

• American • Southampton

Booked 17 times today

Shippy's in Southampton has been a beacon of American cuisine since its inception in 1954. Under the guiding hand of John Betts, former CEO of McDonald's Canada, the restaurant has flourished, offering a menu that balances cherished classics with exciting new additions. Patrons frequently commend the "delicious" food and "super friendly" staff, emphasizing the restaurant's commitment to quality and community. A standout feature is its locally sourced comfort food, which includes American favorites made with fresh ingredients. Reviewers rave about the "melt in your mouth" Reuben and the "outstanding" sizzling steak, highlighting Shippy's as the quintessential American dining experience in Southampton. Perfect for family meals or a casual outing, Shippy's is praised for its "great atmosphere" and "friendly service," making it a must-visit for anyone craving authentic American fare.

A photo of Bridgehampton Inn Restaurant restaurant

2. Bridgehampton Inn Restaurant

4.8

Exceptional(589)

Price: Expensive

• American • Bridgehampton

Booked 3 times today

At the Bridgehampton Inn Restaurant in Bridgehampton, the essence of French cuisine is celebrated with finesse and a deep respect for seasonal ingredients. With a bi-weekly changing menu that offers over 800 recipes a year, this establishment ensures every visit is uniquely delightful. Patrons rave about the authenticity and creativity of the dishes, with one reviewer exclaiming it's the "**VERY BEST RESTAURANT IN ALL OF THE HAMPTONS**." The restaurant's atmosphere, with its blend of modern and traditional decor, complements the exquisite dining experience. Specialties like the "flawless" foie gras and expertly cooked halibut highlight their commitment to French culinary excellence, making every meal a testament to the skillful blending of tradition and innovation.

A photo of Southampton Publick House restaurant

3. Southampton Publick House

4.5

Awesome(39)

Price: Moderate

• American • Southampton

Booked 4 times today

Southampton Publick House stands out as the quintessential Sports Bar, located in the heart of Southampton Village. This establishment is consistently praised for its vibrant atmosphere and exceptional offerings, making it a favorite among locals and visitors alike. Patrons rave about the "best burgers in Southampton" and the "amazing experience" watching sports games, highlighted by enthusiastic reviews such as "Best place to watch the rangers win!" With 21 flatscreen TVs and a welcoming staff that includes standout bartenders like Andre & Jamie, it’s no wonder it’s a go-to spot. The Publick House combines great food, live music, and sports viewing to create a truly authentic and enjoyable Sports Bar experience.

4. North Sea Tavern

3.9

Excellent(35)

Price: Moderate

• American • Southampton

Please join us at the North Sea Tavern for good food, a wide variety of beer, wine & spirits & a comfortable atmosphere. Be on the lookout for our weekly & special events.

5. 1770 House

4.9

Exceptional(1463)

Price: Very Expensive

• American • East Hampton

Booked 11 times today

Honored to be one of Open Table's 2017 Top 100 Restaurants in America.The 1770 House, located in the heart of East Hampton is the Hampton's premier fine dining location. The 1770 House proudly offers three different dining settings to choose from. Our luxurious main dining room, the casual Tavern, or the beautiful outdoor garden patio.

A photo of The Restaurant at Baron's Cove restaurant

6. The Restaurant at Baron's Cove

4.2

Awesome(61)

Price: Expensive

• American • Sag Harbor

Booked 5 times today

The Restaurant at Baron’s Cove in Sag Harbor is a seafood lover's paradise, celebrated for its high-quality, fresh offerings. With its "Best of Award of Excellence" from Wine Spectator in 2018, the restaurant continues to impress with its delightful seafood dishes. Diners rave about the "succulent fish and buttery lobster rolls," highlighting the authenticity and freshness of the cuisine. The seafood, sourced locally, includes "scallops that were amazing" and "oysters that were fresh and delicious." Set against the picturesque backdrop of the harbor, every meal here is an unforgettable experience. As one reviewer put it, "The food was excellent, and the choices for a restaurant week were exceptional." Baron's Cove is undoubtedly a top destination for superb seafood dining in Sag Harbor.

7. Tillie's

4.3

Awesome(165)

Price: Moderate

• American • Montauk

Located at Gurney's Montauk Resort, Tillie’s is an inviting American kitchen that serves breakfast and lunch daily. Guests will enjoy Tillie’s menu of seasonal comfort classics, inspired by local Montauk produce.

8. The Clubhouse

4.5

Awesome(233)

Price: Expensive

• American • East Hampton

Booked 6 times today

New American Cuisine, across from the airport. The Clubhouse offers entertainment and a dining experience unlike any other in The Hamptons. Our expansive location bids a unique layout capable of any event imaginable. Jump into a game of mini golf near our outside bar, get lost in over 40 gaming options in the arcade, shoot some pool, wind down with live music, or enjoy our 10 lanes of bowling. Our dining areas can host any type of celebration, inside or outside, and incorporate lounge areas and stages to unwind after work or simply for leisure. Let us be your favorite sports bar on gameday. We have 23 TVs so you can root for your favorite team while enjoying some of the best local cuisine. Our menus always feature fresh ingredients combined with flavors that are easy on the palate. The Clubhouse is a modern year-round venue filled with adventure. Bring your family, a group of friends, or your favorite coworkers and find out for yourself! Please contact us with any event inquiries.

A photo of Cove Hollow Tavern restaurant

9. Cove Hollow Tavern

4.5

Awesome(519)

Price: Expensive

• American • East Hampton

Booked 13 times today

Cove Hollow Tavern in East Hampton is a beacon of New American cuisine, celebrated for its authentic and rustic seasonal fare. With a commitment to using locally sourced ingredients and classic cooking techniques, this charming spot ensures every dish is crafted to perfection. Diners rave about the "fantastic service" and the "friendly staff," with one guest highlighting, "all of the food from the bread to the brownie were divine, flawless." Whether it's the delightful lobster tacos or the praised Mahi Mahi, every meal is a testament to quality and authenticity. Cove Hollow Tavern is not just a meal; it's a vibrant culinary experience that captures the essence of American dining, making it a must-visit in the Hamptons.

10. M.J. Dowling's

4.6

Exceptional(263)

Price: Moderate

• American • Sag Harbor

Booked 8 times today

Welcome to M.J. Dowling's Steakhouse and Tavern in the charming neighborhood of Sag Harbor, where the spirit of American cuisine is celebrated with gusto! Known for its friendly, pub-like atmosphere and a menu that caters to all, M.J. Dowling's has become a local favorite. Patrons rave about the "delicious corned beef and cabbage" and "fabulous beef sliders," highlighting the quality and authenticity of its offerings. The restaurant is also famous for its "always enjoyable" service and family-friendly amenities, including a popular game room. Whether it's the "amazing steak sandwich" or the nightly specials, M.J. Dowling's consistently delivers a quintessentially American dining experience that's both affordable and enjoyable. As one reviewer puts it, "Just give it a try & you’ll be a regular!"

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

See what locals rave about

From verified diners like you

T
ThomasVIP
New York City •6 reviews
5.0
Dined 6 days ago
Truly a wonderful dinning experience. Service was impeccable, atmosphere warm and pleasant, and the food was fantastic. Apps we had the baked calms and lobster bisque, both amazing. For our mains, we had the pork cheeks and rabbit leg, again top notch. Dessert was truly the cherry on top of the meal. My only feedback would be, they need to serve a glass of whiskey in a proper rocks glass and use large cube ice vs, crushed iced.
More info
1770 HousePrice: Very Expensive• American• East Hampton
•
4.9
M
MarkVIP
New York City •2 reviews
5.0
Dined 6 days ago
Always a great experience. The pretzel is always a perfect start!
More info
Shippy'sPrice: Moderate• German• Southampton
•
4.6
M
MarilynVIP
New York City •42 reviews
5.0
Dined 7 days ago
Fantastic service from John and Elena. Food was over the top. Will certainly return.
More info
Bridgehampton Inn RestaurantPrice: Expensive• French American• Bridgehampton
•
4.8
J
James
New York City •58 reviews
5.0
Dined on 15 Dec 2024
Always hesitate to leave a positive review because it only means a favorite eating place will get even more jammed. That said, we like coming to the Public House. The atmosphere is relaxed, the food is plentiful and generally quite delicious. Julia our server was especially friendly, but without intruding. After taking our orders, she checked back several times to see if everything was ok and/or if we needed anything more. (On other occasions, Marsha has been great, but she does not work on Saturdays). The food was good. New England Clam Chowder. French Onion Soup & Chopped Wedge Salads were delicious. Wings were good; Chicken Picatta less so because the lemon sauce with capers tasted definitely like an add on instead of being infused into the chicken. All in all, however, it was another good evening... and a good dinner. We'll be back!
More info
Southampton Publick HousePrice: Moderate• Contemporary American• Southampton
•
4.5
RV
RayV
New York City •21 reviews
4.0
Dined on 18 Feb 2024
Neighborhood gem - lots of locals (we were not) and reminded me of the taverns/bars of the 70's/80's. We felt very comfortable there.
More info
North Sea TavernPrice: Moderate• American• Southampton
•
3.9

Explore OpenTable

Water Mill

American

Best American Restaurants in Water Mill

Price

Regions

Areas

Top Rated

Dining Options

Seating options

Accessibility

10 restaurants available nearby

1. Shippy's

2. Bridgehampton Inn Restaurant

3. Southampton Publick House

4. North Sea Tavern

5. 1770 House

6. The Restaurant at Baron's Cove

7. Tillie's

8. The Clubhouse

9. Cove Hollow Tavern

10. M.J. Dowling's

See what locals rave about

Explore OpenTable