Best Burgers Restaurants in Caldwell

Food was amazing! Service was also very good and attentive. It is pretty small in there (which is obviously not a foreign concept in NYC) and I know they can only do so much about. While I didn’t mind being placed at the community table, I could see how this would not be welcomed depending on who your neighbors are; can only have so much privacy. I embraced it though! Had a charm with the projector in the back playing the 3 stooges.

Absolutely wonderful meal with incredible service. Hands down the best French onion soup I've ever had. Really great cocktails too!

Overall everything was great from our server Roccos’s attentiveness and professionalism to the food. However, given the pricing certain items should have a better size portion. For example the sliders should at least be a serving of 4 burgers not 3 and the meatballs the same instead of 2 small meatballs. Would definitely revisit in the future.

The GM Maggie, is absolutely fantastic— kind, helpful and funny! The food and drinks are always solid — she will bring us back!

5 Napkin Burger is my favorite place to dine when in the Times Square area before or after going to the theater or if just if in the area.