Best Comfort Food Restaurants in West Allis

First time visiting. Awesome atmosphere! Wonderful staff, excellent food & drinks. Be sure to make reservations.

My wife and I had a wonderful time at Maggiano’s on Wednesday, January 1, 2025. We ate at the bar area. Lucas and his coworker (unfortunately I didn’t get her name), provided us with excellent service. The food as usual was delicious.

This is southern cooking at it’s finest! We shared the Fried Green Tomatoes which were absolutely delicious. We also each ordered the Banana Creme Brulee Chicken & Waffles which were outstanding. We will be returning the next time we are in Milwaukee!

We took our family to Buckley's for an after Christmas fine dining experience. It was wonderful! We were guided to our table upon entry to this beautiful spot. The decor is lovely: black and white upholstery on chairs and bolsters. Bluish-green walls and white trimmed woodwork. It is a very lovely place. We had the best waitress who was very conversational and friendly. She was a sommelier, as well and was very knowledgeable discussing wines with our two sons who really know wines. They picked out two bottles during the evening that were perfect for my tastes. She was also very attentive and moved the meal at a perfect speed. Our food was wonderful. We had a few starters--sourdough bread with chive butter and fried artichoke hearts. Very tasty and different. The entrees were the perfect size--not too much food. My son's steak was just right, my scallops dish was just what I wanted, my husband's salmon was delicious. Our other sons loved their meals, too. And desserts were fabulous!

No contest, best Italian in the city! Impossible to pick just one favorite item on the menu!