Best Italian Restaurants in Carnegie Hill

416 restaurants available nearby

A photo of Carmine's - 44th Street - NYC restaurant

1. Carmine's - 44th Street - NYC

4.6

Exceptional(29784)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Theater District

Booked 314 times today

Carmine's on 44th Street in NYC's Theater District embodies the essence of Southern Italian cuisine, offering a dining experience akin to an Italian American wedding feast. Guests rave about the "abundant portions" and "authentic flavors," highlighting dishes like the "best chicken Parm ever" and "fantastic lasagna." Known for its family-style servings, Carmine's creates a convivial atmosphere where "every meal feels like a Sunday afternoon at Grandma's." Reviewers consistently praise the "amazing atmosphere" and "excellent service," making it a must-visit for both locals and tourists seeking a traditional yet exceptional Italian meal in the heart of Times Square.

2. Bad Roman

4.5

Awesome(2214)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Upper West Side

Booked 203 times today

Nestled in the vibrant Upper West Side of New York, Bad Roman emerges as a beacon of exceptional Steak cuisine, blending modern Italian flair with impeccable quality. This lively eatery from Quality Branded consistently delights its patrons with dishes that are both innovative and delectably satisfying. A standout dish, the steak with cacio e pepe ravioli, receives rave reviews for its sublime flavor fusion, described by a diner as "AMAZING!!!" The filet mignon meatballs, another celebrated choice, are renowned as "the best ever," ensuring that each bite is a testament to the restaurant's commitment to culinary excellence. The effusive praise for Bad Roman's service and ambiance only enhances the dining experience, making it a must-visit destination for steak lovers in the city.

3. Sfoglia

4.8

Exceptional(1978)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Upper East Side

Booked 15 times today

Sfoglia is a lovely little trattoria residing on an unassuming stretch of the Upper East Side, across the street from the 92nd Street Y. Farmhouse tables topped with the season's produce are the appropriate setting for Sfoglia's country Italian fare. The private dining room tucked away upstairs can seat an intimate party of twelve.

A photo of Quality Italian - New York restaurant

4. Quality Italian - New York

4.7

Exceptional(6106)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Midtown West

Booked 181 times today

Nestled in the heart of Midtown Manhattan, Quality Italian is a culinary gem that offers more than just a meal; it promises an authentic Italian dining experience. Renowned for its innovative Italian dishes with a twist, like the crowd-favorite chicken parm pizza and the luxurious spicy lobster rigatoni, this restaurant ensures every dish is a delight. Patrons rave about the "outstanding" lobster pasta and "excellent" service, emphasizing the attentive and knowledgeable staff. One diner exclaimed, "Best Italian food I’ve had in a while!" making Quality Italian a must-visit for anyone seeking a top-tier Italian meal in New York City.

A photo of Carmine's - 91st Street - NYC restaurant

5. Carmine's - 91st Street - NYC

4.6

Exceptional(8499)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Upper West Side

Booked 148 times today

Carmine's on 91st Street in NYC’s Upper West Side is a beacon of Contemporary Italian cuisine, where every meal is a festive celebration akin to an Italian American wedding feast. Known for its generous family-style servings, Carmine's delights diners with meticulously crafted Southern Italian dishes. As one diner raves, "The food never disappoints. It's always a great experience." From the succulent Chicken Parmesan to the divine pasta with sauce, every dish is a testament to authentic Italian flavors, prepared with a contemporary twist. The ambiance is lively and welcoming, perfect for large groups or a family dinner, making every visit to Carmine's a memorable culinary journey.

A photo of Sandro's Restaurant restaurant

6. Sandro's Restaurant

4.9

Exceptional(989)

Price: Very Expensive

• Italian • Upper East Side

Booked 11 times today

Sandro's, a cherished family-run establishment, offers an authentic Roman dining experience. Chef Sandro Fioriti crafts timeless Roman dishes, while his wife Anna and son Sandro Jr. oversee the restaurant's day to day operations. Eschewing flashy decor and modern tunes, Sandro's ambiance transports guests to Italy, with its traditional cuisine and exclusively Italian wine selection, constantly evolving to delight wine enthusiasts.WHEN BOOKING PLEASE NOTE THE SEATING OPTION YOU ARE BOOKING FOR. BAR is for seats at the BAR, and DINING ROOM is for tables in the restaurant. We will do our best to accommodate any seating requests but cannot guarantee accommodation. As a busy establishment with limited space, we kindly ask that large strollers may be turned away to ensure a comfortable dining experience for all our guests.If you have any questions or concerns, please feel free to call us. We appreciate your understanding and cooperation.

A photo of Aunt Jake's Pasta Experience restaurant

7. Aunt Jake's Pasta Experience

4.9

Exceptional(811)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Upper East Side

Booked 73 times today

Aunt Jake's Pasta Experience on New York’s Upper East Side offers a truly authentic and interactive Italian dining adventure. Renowned for its hands-on pasta-making classes followed by a delectable 3-course meal, Aunt Jake's ensures every guest not only eats like an Italian but learns the art too. Patrons rave about the quality and ambiance, with glowing reviews like, "This was one of the best pasta making experiences I’ve had. & the food .. omg delicious" and "Anthony was amazing! Overall, we had such a great experience." Whether it's a fun date night, a family gathering, or a solo culinary escapade, Aunt Jake’s provides an exceptional blend of education, entertainment, and gastronomic delight, making every visit memorable.

A photo of Tony's Di Napoli - Midtown restaurant

8. Tony's Di Napoli - Midtown

4.8

Exceptional(18270)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Theater District

Booked 170 times today

Located in the bustling Theater District of New York, Tony's Di Napoli - Midtown is a gem for steak lovers. Known for its generous family-style platters, Tony's offers an authentic taste of Southern Neapolitan cuisine, with a special nod to high-quality steak that keeps diners coming back. Guests rave about the "outstanding food," with glowing reviews frequently highlighting the steak's superb flavor and perfect preparation. One reviewer enthused, "The food is always fresh and tasty, service is top-notch," underscoring the consistent quality and exceptional service that make Tony's a must-visit for anyone craving a stellar steak experience in NYC.

9. Becco

4.5

Awesome(28556)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Theater District

Booked 120 times today

Lidia Bastianich & her son Joe's Theater District mainstay. Best known for the $29.95 pasta tasting menu & the great selections on the $35 Italian wine list. Loved by locals & out of towners alike, Becco has been serving consistently delicious regional Italian cuisine since 1993. Located on the famed Restaurant Row in NYC's Theatre District, Becco is open for lunch & dinner seven days a week. Enjoy signature dishes, like the Osso Bucco, as well as the bounty of fresh seasonal preparations. The Reserve Wine list has many of Italy's best known producers, as well as some more eclectic wine makers. A knowledgeable staffer will be on hand to help you make a great choice. With 18 years on restaurant row, great food & great service help make Becco the right choice time & time again.

10. Sistina

4.7

Exceptional(1655)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Upper East Side

Booked 16 times today

WE DON’T RESERVE SPECIFIC TABLES WHICHEVER TABLE WE HAVE UPON YOUR ARRIVAL IS WHERE YOU WILL BE SEATEDWE DON’T HAVE HIGHCHAIRS OR BOOSTER SEATS & WE DON’T ALLOW STROLLERS INDOORSWE DON’T PERMIT OUTSIDE ITEMS (liquor,flowers & cake) PARTIES OF 6 OR MORE: LET US KNOW 1 DAY IN ADVANCE IF YOU DECREASE YOUR PARTY SIZE TO AVOID THE $150 PER PERSON CHARGESistina restaurant, one of the most highly rated Italian restaurants in New York City, has been impressing its sophisticated clientele for over 40 years. Host/owner/chef Giuseppe Bruno, the Zagat Survey's "Host of the Year", is responsible for every aspect of his restaurant, from greeting his devoted patrons, to preparing special meals and dishes upon request.CANCELLATION POLICY: If you wish to cancel your reservation please let us know a minimum of 24 hours in advance. Failure to notify the restaurant will result in a $50 cancelation fee per person in the group.DRESS CODE: We politely ask that you please avoid SHORTS & FLIP FLOPS.

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

See what locals rave about

From verified diners like you

S
Sarah
New York City •1 review
5.0
Dined today
I don’t recall his name but our server was outstanding! Pleasant, fun, and helpful. The family talked about what a great vibe he brought to dinner! We go as a family every time we go to NYC (our third trip) and food is always delicious, with PLENTY to go around. Also appreciated the water pitcher on the table. As a large family (table of 9), it’s so much easier to keep the water glasses full ourselves. Thanks again!!
More info
Carmine's - 44th Street - NYCPrice: Moderate• Italian• Theater District
•
4.6
L
Lynn
New York City •2 reviews
5.0
Dined 1 day ago
Absolutely outstanding! We can’t wait to come back!
More info
Bad RomanPrice: Expensive• Italian• Upper West Side
•
4.5
J
JonVIP
St. Louis •9 reviews
5.0
Dined 1 day ago
Spot on with service, great wine selection, our meal was excellent and every plate went back empty. Amazing meals all around.
More info
Quality Italian - New YorkPrice: Expensive• Italian• Midtown West
•
4.7
T
Teri
Greater Boston •3 reviews
5.0
Dined 6 days ago
Our first time at Becco. Lovely cozy atmosphere. Feels like being in Italy. We needed to make a 1:00 theater, and our waiter was very attentive , personable and accommodating. Menu selections are ample. Prices reasonable. I had the bransini white fish with leeks and roasted potatoes. Partner had the pasta trio. Becco house Caesar salad comes with is outstanding Everything was delicious. Will certainly recommend to our friends.
More info
BeccoPrice: Expensive• Italian• Theater District
•
4.5
T
Tracy
Calgary / Southern Alberta •14 reviews
5.0
Dined on 16 Dec 2024
Absolutely LOVED our first time at Carmines! From the service to the food everything was spectacular. It felt like we were part of the family and not only did Sarah, our sever, make sure we were well taken care of but everyone else who took our plates or tidied our table was so attentive and friendly. Definitely one of those core memory experiences. 10/10 Carmines…we will see you again :)
More info
Carmine's - 91st Street - NYCPrice: Expensive• Italian• Upper West Side
•
4.6

Explore OpenTable

Carnegie Hill

Italian

Best Italian Restaurants in Carnegie Hill

Price

Regions

Areas

Top Rated

Dining Options

Seating options

Award-winning

Accessibility

416 restaurants available nearby

1. Carmine's - 44th Street - NYC

2. Bad Roman

3. Sfoglia

4. Quality Italian - New York

5. Carmine's - 91st Street - NYC

6. Sandro's Restaurant

7. Aunt Jake's Pasta Experience

8. Tony's Di Napoli - Midtown

9. Becco

10. Sistina

See what locals rave about

Explore OpenTable