Best Oyster Bars in Shelter Island / San Diego Bay

Some of the best dinners are spent at Eddie Vs! The food. The service. Beyond delightful

As always, Eddie V's is an exceptional choice for fabulous food, attentive service (Crystal is amazing), incredible cocktails, and delightful ambience. Happy Hour offerings, in particular, are perfectly sized, delicious, and affordable. First-timers will NOT be disappointed!

Our niece was in town with her new husband and met us there for lunch. It was also her birthday. My husband and I have eaten at the Brigantine many times and thought this would be a great place for a birthday luncheon. Michael, our server, was very understanding that we didn't want very fast service as we had a lot of family news to catch up. As usual the dinks and food were great. I was particularly pleased with my Oysters Rockefeller. The portions for our meals were just right and we had a little room leftover to dig into my niece's birthday desert. All in all, a great experience, as usual.

From start to finish, we walked in , got our table right away. Our server Nick was supper helpful in introducing us to the new dishes and was prompt with drinks. We did get there around 6pm so the dinner rush was just about to get going, are we were still well taken care of. The food was very good and locally sourced dished were DLISH! Well Done Nick!

Our server, Skyler, was just about as perfect as one can be. Very attentive, helpful, engaging, and pleasant, and she visited our table just as often as we needed. The food was really good. Their Crab and Shrimp Cobb Salad is one of the most enjoyable takes on the Cobb Salad I've ever had. We celebrated my wife's 75th birthday on this visit, and we three all enjoyed the crème brûlée Skyler surprised us with. A good place to go for good food, drink, service, and a relatively quiet dining room, for those of us old enough to enjoy conversation.