Best Seafood Restaurants in Sanibel

We were a party of 5, 2 of which were children. Everything was delicious! Calamari, my stuffed lobster, steaks, miso fish, cocktails were delicious! Kids meal also 5 star! The show stopper was the carrot cake! It was a very generous portion and the perfect ending to our meal. Our server was wonderful! She took great care of us!! Everything was perfect I even purchased a gift card as a Christmas gift! We will definitely return!!

Living in Naples for the past 25 years, Ive seen many restaurants open to rave reviews, and close within 3 years. Tony Ridgeway is a local restauranteur who understands what people want, what is trendy, and what is a tried and true" menu item. I love both his restaurants. Everything is always excellent. At Bayside today we both had the traditional Thanksgiving turkey dinner that was fantastic. He used REAL turkeys, Both white meat and dark were on our plates. and everyone knows the white meat is easy to slice, but the dark meat always comes out in chunks. That's what we had. No processed "turkey roast" that most places serve. Thank you Tony for a delightful Holiday dinner!

Great views of Naples Bay, food is exceptional for reasonable value and the wait staff and staff overall take upmost pride and appreciation for thier customers, their service and your experience at their establishment. Have frequented this restaurant several times and will continue to. Highly recommend if you have not already, you will not be disappointed.

We thoroughly enjoyed our dining experience this evening at Ocean Prime. We were very happy we tried this restaurant. We were celebrating a birthday and were seated at the open side window section so we could enjoy the lovely warm evening. We were impressed that we were not cramped into a small table for two but instead a table for 4 so lots of room. Tables are well spaced in this section so you feel like you can enjoy a private dinner. ( the inside area seemed a bit noiser) Our server was Todd who was delightful and didn't make us feel rushed one bit. We selected off the early dinner menu and enjoyed our choices. Scallops with ricotto were perfect, 4 very large scalloped cooked just right and Filet steak which was delicious and cooked to order. Salad and lobster bisque were also very enjoyable. We hardly had room for dessert but decided to try the carrot layered cake and the peanut butter chocolate cake which were both wonderful ( took half home!) As a birthday celebration they sent me home with another lovely dessert from the menu. All in all Ocean prime offers a lovely evening out, treats the diner to a relaxing paced dinner and the staff were all kind, pleasant and efficient. Thanks you for a nice Birthday Dinner!!

Marco Prime is the best on the island. We eat here often and it never disappoints. The seafood is delicious and the steaks are always cooked to perfection. Our favorites include the scallops, wedge salad, mac and cheese, and you can’t go wrong with any steak on the menu.