Best Seafood Restaurants in West Indy

The food was good, but the filet wasn't as tender as as it usually is. The waitress was a little absent at times.

I took customers, and they all loved it. Such a great storied history. Fabulous food. Excellent service.

Of St Elmo’s, Hyde Park, Capital Grille, and Ruth’s Chris, this is the best place to get a fantastic steal and drinks in Indianapolis. The drinks were great and I loved the steak and dessert. Popovers were good as well. Nothing was bad. Service was great. we went to Mel’s downstairs after and that place is the bomb. GO HERE NOW!!

I celebrated my birthday here. The staff was amazing everyone was friendly and they all signed the birthday card I was given made the experience very personal. I appreciated that! The food was amazing! We ordered a Caesar salad and crab cake as a starter the crab cake was like butter it was so soft and melted in your mouth! The ribeye was cooked to perfection the searing on the steaks is chef’s kiss! Lobster Mac & cheese was very delicious! I will definitely be back to try more! Thank you for a wonderful experience!

We splurge once a year to come here and it never disappoints. It’s not super fancy so we don’t feel out of place, but it’s a very nice place for a special date night. The food and drinks are always delicious. This visit I got the filet which was *chefs kiss* as always, but the brussel sprouts were where the meal really shined. The toasted ravioli appetizer was perfect. My husband loves the shrimp cocktail, with the signature famous cocktail sauce they share with their sister restaurant St. Elmo’s. If you’ve somehow never tried this gem, do yourself a favor and go. Worth every penny.