Best Steakhouses in East Setauket

Best steakhouse in Long Island. Great service. Great atmosphere. Great food. Ty.

Invited a few new bees tonight for the porterhouse for 2 special and we weren't disappointed. This restaurant is outstanding very consistent with great service,food and wine. Highly recommend

We have been to Rothman's many times and always enjoy our experience. The food is always excellent. My personal preference is the porterhouse. Our server was amazing, very attentive, kind and courteous. It was our wedding anniversary, and it was so nice that this was recognized. It makes it extra special. Just a suggestion if booking for an anniversary or birthday, request main dining room. It's much more romantic and livelier.

Fantastic dining experience. The staff was attentive, the food was excellent prices are a bit high, but that is what you get these days. Great value highly recommend

Beautiful restaurant from the minute you open the door! We were seated immediately and the server was quickly to meet and greet us. We had the rigatoni appetizer which we split- perfect! Very filling- we both head meat choices and the steaks were to die for! Baked potatoes and vegetables were top notch. Highly recommended and will definitely be back!