Best Steakhouses in Castro Valley

Food and service was excellent. Tuesday dinner special was a great value for a three course meal.

We chose this restaurant for a birthday celebration, and it did not disappoint! Cathy, our server, was fantastic and made the experience enjoyable. The food was reasonably priced and of great quality. The steaks were perfectly cooked to our request, the sides were tasty, and the clam chowder was outstanding. The staff was incredibly accommodating when I requested to add two extra people to our reservation, and I appreciated that they allowed side substitutions without any additional charge. Overall, a wonderful experience! We will be back. The Smiths

I loved it ! I celebrated my birthday with my parents Of course! Dining at Mastro’s was an exquisite experience from start to finish. I indulged in the 12oz fillet, which was flawlessly cooked to a tender perfection, exuding rich, savory flavors. The mashed potatoes were smooth and creamy, while the mac & cheese was delicious. & of course I treated myself to the butter cake—a decadent masterpiece that was perfectly moist and delicately sweet. The service was impeccable, with attentive and courteous staff ensuring a seamless dining experience. Mastro’s delivers culinary excellence in an elegant setting, and I eagerly anticipate my next visit.

Very nice experience! We were seated pretty quickly and our server/bartender did an excellent job keeping up with our orders and even though he had two jobs (maybe they were short that night), he was as attentive and friendly as he could be, and the margaritas were excellent!

Excellent steak, service and understated ambiance made our dinner most enjoyable. Thank you for a pleasant relaxing dinner…we will return!