Diners' Choice: Best Overall restaurants in Muskoka

OpenTable

Updated 05 December 2024

Looking for the best overall restaurants in Muskoka? You’re in the right place. Each month, OpenTable analyses nearly 2 million global diner reviews from the past four months. We sort the results by location and category to help you discover new favourite restaurants. It's a great partnership: you reserve, eat, and review. We listen...and deliver the results for all to benefit. Enjoy!

The Pearl Muskoka

4.7

4.7 (89)

CAN$31 to CAN$50

Global, International

Bala

About the restaurant

Located in the heart of Bala, Muskoka, The Pearl is a destination food market during the day & vibin snack bar at night where “old country” and contemporary intersect. Led by a team of culinary experts, focused on mixing flavor-driven cuisine with the simplicity and comforts of cottage life.

What started as a vision of a cool, welcoming spot in the heart of Muskoka was then explored, researched and fine-tuned by TOBEN Hospitality Group owners Toben Kochman, Elana Kochman and Ryan Feldman. After putting their heads together and harmonizing their ideas, they arrived at The Pearl.

The Dinner Menu at the Pearl continuously evolves and focuses on communal eats in the form of small & large share plates or "tapas". It is the perfect atmosphere for guests to disconnect from their day and reconnect with one another.

Top review

DuncanVIP

Dined on 14 Sept 2024

Amazing staff and food quality. Great experience.

Beveragino

4.7

4.7 (212)

CAN$51 and over

Mediterranean

Port Carling

About the restaurant

Beveragino, Port Carling

CLOSED FOR THE SEASON!!

Thank you to all our valued guests this season we appreciate the support. We look forward to serving you and providing a great experience next season.

Thank you - Beveragino Team

Top review

Michael J

Dined on 2 Nov 2024

Very nice dining experience - very friendly and attentive staff, excellent food (my wife and I had the risotto and gnocchi - both were terrific). I would certainly go back on a future trip to the Muskoka area.

Dock of the Bay

4.6

4.6 (743)

CAN$51 and over

Steakhouse

Gravenhurst

About the restaurant

Born out of our love of fine wines and delicious food, Dock of the Bay - Gravenhurst has become the premiere location for casual dining in Muskoka. After traveling the world and sampling different cuisines, we decided to make our way back home and bring the world to us.

Chef Darren serves gourmet meals prepared with only the freshest produce. We ensure the quality of our dishes with the quality of our ingredients.

Our biggest challenge was finding the right, high-quality ingredients for the dishes we wanted to serve. We are dedicated to offering only the finest and freshest foods. We have also taken great care in assembling a team of only the best chefs, experienced kitchen and servers.

Reservation is available for dinner only.

Top review

NatalieVIP

Dined on 11 Oct 2024

Amazing experience! Service was great! Accommodating to food allergies. Try the sliders they are amazing!

Vintages at Sherwood Inn Resort

4.5

4.5 (124)

CAN$31 to CAN$50

Global, International

Port Carling

About the restaurant

Sherwood Inn's Vintages Restaurant offers exceptional culinary fare on the shores of Muskoka's Lake Joseph for breakfast, lunch and dinner. Well known for its elegant décor, delectable cuisine, exceptional service and award winning wine list - Vintages at Sherwood has been a long standing favourite for both resort guests and the public. Vintages is the ideal Muskoka restaurant for a romantic meal, group dining party or celebrating a special occasion in style. Join us for live music on the patio most Fridays, and every long weekend Sunday this summer!

In addition to the extensive selection of appetizers, entrees, and deserts offered on the dining room menu, Vintages’ Executive Chef will often prepare special menus in celebration of holidays and special occasions including Valentine’s, Easter, Thanksgiving, Christmas, New Year's and more! Our Chefs and their Culinary Team strive to ensure all guests enjoy an extraordinary dining experience.

Top review

kate

Dined on 19 Oct 2024

Food was excellent at Vintages.The roasted ontario rack of lamb is the best I had ever eaten.

Stella's Lounge @ Jack & Stella

4.6

4.6 (94)

CAN$31 to CAN$50

Italian

Bala

About the restaurant

The Lounge @ Jack & Stella offers our customers a little bit of everything.

Our goal it to be your destination, that place where you want to come and can’t wait to bring a friend. The home away from home where your kids want to go and will remember for years to come. A place where friends will meet on a Saturday afternoon by boat or girlfriends will save the date for that special getaway weekend.

Top review

Michelle

Dined on 30 Aug 2024

What a great spot! Appetizers on the dock but a storm was blowing in. Staff was awesome to pivot and get us a table inside. Still a great view. Food delicious with a special shout out for cookie and ice cream desert! A definite stop in Bala!

The Antler Steakhouse - Deerhurst Resort

4.5

4.5 (509)

CAN$51 and over

Steakhouse

Huntsville

About the restaurant

This charming loghouse restaurant offers an authentic Muskoka dining experience whether looking for local cuisine, celebrating a special occasion or planning your next date night. From the classic Tomahawk Steak to warm fondue, fresh greens and delightful desserts, The Antler is no longer just for those looking to enjoy a steak. With its cottage-esque ambiance and upscale menu, it’s the perfect spot to make cozy dinner plans. In the warmer months, an outdoor campfire on the patio offers the perfect spot to relax and enjoy the views of the golf course and historic canal between Fairy and Peninsula Lakes.
Reservations are required for dinner – we strongly recommend booking in advance.
Please note Deerhurst is a cashless resort. We accept debit and all major credit cards.

Top review

GlenM

Dined on 12 Dec 2024

Christina was our server and looked after us very well. My wife ordered a Riesling wine , which tasted like a oakey Chardonnay. Christina made the issue go away by offering a very nice Pinot Grigio. Our meal was excellent. Other than the signage that would have helped find the restaurant (the light was burned out) and signage that would have helped us park in the right area....it was an excellent evening.

The Rosseau & Windermere Pub

4.6

4.6 (166)

CAN$31 to CAN$50

Canadian

Muskoka

About the restaurant

Windermere Pub: Casual Dining

Open for a casual relaxing dinning experience. Whether sharing a drink with friends fireside or out for some great food, come relax and enjoy our classic Pub! Reservations available.

The Rosseau - Reopening for Christmas Dec 22-Jan 4 5pm-10pm

The Rosseau: Elevated Dining

The jewel of Lake Rosseau, dining at the Lady of the Lake, or however best describes the culinary experience at Lake Rosseau’s premier dining room and Veranda. Once you’re seated in one of the luxurious dining areas with unparalleled views of Lake Rosseau, an artfully curated and expertly crafted culinary experience awaits. Using a blend of unique and quality ingredients as well as the best products the Muskoka’s have to offer, you’ll dine like no other at The Rosseau.

Top review

Pasquale

Dined 2 days ago

Food was amazing. Pastry chefs desert was out of this world apple cheesecake!!! Thank you Emily! Waiter Andy was excellent re the food knowledge and just all around service. Out of this world Andy! Thank you for all of your expertise! It was truly a great time! Everyone had a wonderful evening! Pasquale and Linda.

Portside Fusion

4.6

4.6 (466)

CAN$31 to CAN$50

Global, International

Port Carling

About the restaurant

Our team strives to bring together the freshest local ingredients to produce a variety of cultural rich dishes. The Muskoka lakes are the crown jewel of Ontario cottage country, and as such we seek to bring the food we feel it deserves.

Top review

JoannahVIP

Dined on 4 Oct 2024

The food is absolutely outstanding. I have not had a better meal in a big city or in a fancy venue which was a delight to discover in a humble location in a small town in Ontario. The chef is extremely talented and the staff team are fun, welcoming and knowledgeable.

Cliffside at Muskoka Bay Resort

4.4

4.4 (407)

CAN$31 to CAN$50

Canadian

Gravenhurst

About the restaurant

Welcome to Cliffside at Muskoka Bay Resort. We are a Four-Season Resort welcoming guests to enjoy a great meal in an amazing atmosphere. Allow our team to provide you and your guests with a unique and exceptional dining experience. We look forward to your visit.

Please contact us for possible additional availability @ 705 687 4900 Ex. 502

Menu: https://muskokabayresort.com/dining#menu

Top review

Doreen

Dined on 28 Nov 2024

Overall it was a lovely evening the appetizers were awesome. Main’s delicious and the before dinner cocktails very unique and tasty. Will go again

Discover more

Wings & Strings - Live Music & Wing Night

Basilico

3.9

3.9 (198)

CAN$30 and under

Italian

Bracebridge

About the restaurant

Basilico

"Local. Distinct. Delicious."

We offer Italian food with options for every appetite.

Our entire menu utilizes the the best local ingredients, prepared from scratch.

We have a great selection of local beers on tap, a unique wine list and an outstanding cocktail menu.

Complete with a stunning view of the Muskoka River; Basilico provides atmosphere for the whole family.

Top review

Chris

Dined on 23 Nov 2024

Outstanding Great place Great people Great servers

Explore Diners' Choice best of Muskoka

Explore more Diners' Choice lists