Best Authentic Restaurants in West Islip

Price

££
£££
££££

Cuisine

AmericanItalianSteakhouseSeafoodFrenchIndian

Regions

NassauSuffolk

Areas

AmityvilleBabylonBay ShoreCommackDeer ParkEast Islip

Top Rated

CharmingFancyGood for business mealsGood for groupsGood for special occasionsGreat for brunch

Dining Options

All dining options

Delivery only

Takeaway only

Seating options

BarCounterStandardHigh TopOutdoor

Accessibility

Gender-neutral toiletWheelchair access

32 restaurants available nearby

A photo of Besito Mexican - West Islip restaurant

1. Besito Mexican - West Islip

4.7

Exceptional(1849)

££££Price: Moderate

• Mexican • West Islip

Booked 16 times today

Upscale option for Mexican fare and cocktails, with private dining available, and a kids' menu.

A photo of Primi Italian Steakhouse restaurant

2. Primi Italian Steakhouse

4.8

Exceptional(1473)

££££Price: Very Expensive

• Italian • West Islip

Booked 24 times today

Primi Italian Steakhouse, located on the South Shore of Long Island, has authentic Italian fare coupled with dry-aged prime steaks. Primi has been one of the leading restaurants to not only dine, but host an intimate and most delicious event! You may dine upstairs in our private room featuring a fireplace and long tables for an intimate affair; in our main dining room under the chandeliers with a speakeasy vibe and retro art design; or in front of our brick fireplace in the Lounge for a more relaxed feel and stimulating atmosphere, and lastly our outdoor Patio. Our 18 seated Gally Bar is filled with the finest liquors, 2 flat screen t.v.'s, and our Wine Cases showcase and house some of the best wines in the World, along with all your favorites! Guest favorites are our specialty...dry-aged steaks and classic Italian dishes!

3. Salt and Barrel

4.8

Exceptional(1693)

££££Price: Expensive

• Contemporary American • Bay Shore

Booked 6 times today

An authentic oyster bar with an urban vibe and vintage soul. Serving classic cocktails, craft taps, and coastal fare with a rotating selection of east/west coast oysters daily.

A photo of Butera's Restaurant of Bay Shore restaurant

4. Butera's Restaurant of Bay Shore

4.7

Exceptional(1002)

££££Price: Moderate

• Italian • Bay Shore

Booked 16 times today

Butera's Restaurant of Bay Shore is a beloved authentic Italian eatery. The owners, known for their traditional rustic Italian cuisine, have been pleasing customers since 1991. As one reviewer put it, 'the food is authentic Italian'. The restaurant's welcoming ambiance, excellent service and variety of menu choices make it a favorite among locals.

5. Pecado Mexican

4.7

Exceptional(501)

££££Price: Expensive

• Contemporary Mexican • Bay Shore

Booked 15 times today

Pecado is highly acclaimed modern Mexican restaurant known for its menu featuring bold flavors and high quality. Offering a sophisticated experience, Pecado will be the perfect place for any occasion. Crafting cocktails use only fresh, seasonal ingredients and offers a vast selection of the finest tequilas and mezcals, as well as a rotating selection of wines from across South America. Whether it’s lunch with a friend, dinner with your family, or a date night hot spot, this is the place to be. With brunch, lunch, and more, there’s something for everyone to enjoy!

A photo of Tres Palms Coastal Dining restaurant

6. Tres Palms Coastal Dining

4.3

Awesome(654)

££££Price: Expensive

• American • Babylon

Booked 1 time today

Here at Tres Palms your dining pleasure is our first priority. We are committed to serving free-range, natural and sustainable poultry and meat, free of any pesticides, hormones or antibiotics, The first thing you will notice is how tasteful and delicious our dishes are when using such proteins as a base ingredient. More people are understanding the ramifications of introducing so many chemicals and antibiotics to our bodies. We created our menu using ingredients found in our local farms and waters, whenever possible. Top ingredients along with a totally relaxed atmosphere and “first in class” service, is how we deliver the Tres Palms’ experience to you , our loyal customer. Come in and enjoy our Sunday Brunch, free docking and live music.

A photo of Blackstone Steakhouse restaurant

7. Blackstone Steakhouse

4.7

Exceptional(6357)

££££Price: Very Expensive

• Steakhouse • Melville

Booked 67 times today

Blackstone Steakhouse features a dazzling array of cuisine, from prime dry aged steaks to amazing sushi and fresh seafood. We also have our own authentic sushi chef, a fabulous raw bar and award winning wine list. Dine or enjoy cocktails al fresco in our outdoor lounge featuring ambient lighting, lush landscaping and ultra-comfortable oversize booths and seating. Our menu is truly unique, combining tantalizing steakhouse classics with amazing sushi and seafood creations. In addition to serving the finest prime dry-aged and Kobe beef, we have our own authentic sushi chef and a fabulous sushi and raw seafood bar. Plus, our sommelier can help you select the perfect wine from our 850 bottle, award-winning wine list to complement your meal.

A photo of Casa Stellina Ristorante restaurant

8. Casa Stellina Ristorante

4.6

Exceptional(230)

££££Price: Expensive

• Italian • Farmingdale

Booked 7 times today

Nestled in the heart of Farmingdale, our newest culinary endeavor emerges as a vibrant extension of our passion for Italian cuisine. Introducing Casa Stellina, a spinoff that radiates the same warmth and authenticity as its predecessor, Stellina Ristorante.Inspired by the bustling energy of Farmingdale, our vision is to create a culinary haven where locals and visitors alike can experience the essence of Italian hospitality. As a nod to our roots, we invite you to embark on a journey reminiscent of the rustic charm and timeless flavors found in the heart of Italy.

A photo of Vico: Pasta e Pizza Napoletano restaurant

9. Vico: Pasta e Pizza Napoletano

4.7

Exceptional(308)

££££Price: Moderate

• Italian • Farmingdale

Booked 5 times today

We stay true to Italy's culinary standards to retain the natural freshness and flavors of our dishes, which makes us one of the ONLY restaurants in the US to never incorporate artificial flavorings, colorings, or preservatives, nor do we use corn syrups in any of our beverages. We take pride in guaranteeing that none of our offerings contain GMO fruits, vegetables, or processed seed oils. Our olive oil, frying oil, flour, and sauce are all imported from Italy, while our meat, seafood and produce are sourced locally. We strive to replicate the culinary experiences that we find when we visit the Amalfi Coast. Our hometown, Vico Equense, is referred to as the “Gateway to the Amalfi Coast” and the "Food Capital of Italy". Directly across from Monte Vesuvio, Vico is rich with the same soil as the San Marzano area. We aim to share the cherished memories cooking with Nonna. It was here that we learned the significance of the food we savor and endeavored to preserve her treasured

10. 317 Main Street

4.7

Exceptional(1701)

££££Price: Moderate

• Gastro Pub • Farmingdale

Booked 3 times today

Chef Eric LeVine uniquely weaves local cuisine into an American Grill, setting himself and “317 Main Street” apart from the many restaurant choices on Long Island. The two time “Chopped” Champion, Chef Eric LeVine is bringing his talents to Farmingdale, a growing destination spot for great food, distinctive cocktails and unbeatable entertainment. For a one of a kind experience, reserve a seat at the Chef’s Table. Watch Chef Eric as he entertains you with his creativity, humor and passion for fresh local food. Craft Cocktails are a favorite at “317 Main Street” where trendy meets fresh. Served up by the best trained mixologists, our cocktails will leave you impressed and quenched.

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

See what locals rave about

From verified diners like you

N
NadineVIP
New York City •12 reviews
5.0
Dined 1 day ago
As always, amazing! The food was excellent. The staff was helpful and kind. Our go to!
More info
Butera's Restaurant of Bay ShorePrice: Moderate• Italian• Bay Shore
•
4.7
D
Drew
New York City •1 review
5.0
Dined 2 days ago
Requested a seat away from the front bar area and bathroom via reservation. Got there to a table in bar area just inside the front door. Brought it to their attention and were apologetic and after a few minutes seated us in a much better area. Service was excellent and the food never disappoints.
More info
Besito Mexican - West IslipPrice: Moderate• Mexican• West Islip
•
4.7
M
MattVIP
Philadelphia County •48 reviews
5.0
Dined 2 days ago
Everyone from the hostess to the water guys, to the bartender, to the waitress were friendly and couldn’t do enough. Delicious filet and mashed potatoes and creamed spinach sides. We also had the halibut special, also delicious. They do everything well.
More info
Primi Italian SteakhousePrice: Very Expensive• Italian• West Islip
•
4.8
C
ChrisVIP
New York City •10 reviews
5.0
Dined 3 days ago
My wife and I had Valentine’s Day Dinner here. The food was unbelievable and the oysters were perfect.
More info
Salt and BarrelPrice: Expensive• Contemporary American• Bay Shore
•
4.8
J
Joseph
New York City •4 reviews
4.0
Dined on 2 Feb 2025
This was not our first visit to Mythos. They were busy but it took a good 10-15 minutes for someone to come by to take our drink order. Additionally, the wait staff does not tell you about off menu offerings unless you specifically ask. The food has always been great but the service, although friendly and polite, needs some polish.
More info
Mythos Authentic Greek CuisinePrice: Expensive• Greek• Bayside
•
4.5

Explore OpenTable

Area
Authentic

West Islip

Bellport
Water Mill
Armonk
Woodbury
Deer Park
Babylon
Oakdale
Jericho
New Hyde Park
Patchogue
Scarsdale
Chappaqua
Melville
Massapequa
Centerport
Smithtown
Sayville
Mount Kisco
Harrison
Southampton