Best Cosy Restaurants in Whitefish Bay

We come very frequently to LPB because we have consistently good experiences. We didn't have a bad experience this time per se, but two things could have been better. First, I ordered the goat cheese tart which I have had several times before. This time, the bottom crust was so tough that I could barely cut it with a knife. A knife, by the way, that was taken from me after my salad course and was not replaced, so I had to borrow one from another table because our server was not in sight. Literally I could barely cut the crust, it nearly went flying off the plate from the force I needed to use to try to break it...I sent it back. Secondly, I was celebrating my birthday tonight. When the server asked for dessert orders, I ordered the profiteroles which I was very excited about. When the dessert finally arrived, she brought the chocolate torte instead. When I told her I had ordered the profiteroles she said that they were coming after and this was the "comped" birthday dessert. Well, I didn't want TWO desserts...I just wanted my profiteroles. C'mon LPB. Really? You can't just give the birthday girl the dessert she actually wants? For the amount of money we have spent over the years there it seems a little outrageous not to give the customer the preferred dessert. It would have been better not to bring a "free" one at all.

Cozy place with a bar. We were seated away from the bar and our server was great. The food was upscale bar food but very tasty. The Bacon Fat Popcorn was a nice addition.

Jack Pandl’s is a classic and I’m so happy it’s still around! The atmosphere is quite lovely and the place is super charming. The wait staff was very attentive, was well-versed in the menu and could make recommendations, and very pleasant. Food was good and portions were large enough that three out of four diners had leftovers. We treated ourselves to dessert, including the strawberry schaum torte, chocolate mousse pie, and apple strudel. The chocolate mousse was the best and I highly recommend. The others were good, but the mousse stood out. I thought the prices were reasonable for what we ordered and look forward to going back soon. 

The service and food were great, will definitely go back.

Perfect place to have a quick bite to eat before a Bucks game. Food was great Had a smash burger and fries. And the wait staff were fabulous!