Best Fine Dining Restaurants in Pewaukee

Quality and Consistency is an expectation of all Bartolotta and The Commodore checks the box’s for all of those. The setting on Lake Nagawicka is the bow on top. Our daughter’s wedding reception will be there next year and we are so excited to know that every detail will be covered.

We hosted a family Christmas dinner for 14 and were amazed by the setting and the food but most importantly our waiter Mike's outstanding service! His ability to read the room, recommend just the right plates to share and bring his personal stories and engagement was a delight. Having only done brunch here before we had no idea just how nuanced, succulent, unique and savory each shared dinner dish would be. Will definitely be back!

I had a wonderful dining event with my group. I asked for a simple accommodation and they made it happen. This enhanced our dining experience. A great team of people that pay attention to detail makes this restaurant successful and makes customers come back to enjoy more dining experiences.

Nice evening put..excellent service and food. Steak and Salmon were top notch...

We return again and again due to the veteran servers like Karen, the ambience, and the kitchen magic.