Best Restaurants with Private Rooms in South Street Seaport

Loved this place!! The ambiance is fantastic and the food is even better. We wanted something nice for a birthday, but nothing over the top. This place was perfect. Also— get the pistachio gelato. Its amazing.

Spectacular food. We explored the museum first, and we thought our time in the restaurant afterwards might just be an unremarkable add-on to the amazing history of the place. But the food ITSELF is some of the best we’ve ever had in our 30 years of living in New York. It’s a bit pricey, but it’s what I expect to pay for food at this level of excellence. Truly delicious. Worth every penny. Cannot wait to go back. The Founding Fathers were there! It’s a thrill to read about everything that happened there and then sit down where George Washington himself had meals and drinks. You get to step back in time, feel a close connection to our incredible history, AND eat some of the best food of your life.

They didn't have the reservation in their system, but they accommodated us just the same. Excellent service, decent food.

Amazing menu and great environment with top tier service.

Exceptional experience and I will be back next time I travel to NYC. The food was delicious, the cocktails were innovative and fun, and the service and ambiance were impeccable. We traveled with someone with celiac and our server and the chef made sure she could eat literally everything ordered. I'd give more than 5 stars if that were possible! Delighted to have visited such a wonderful establishment on our trip.