Best Restaurants with a Fireplace in Water Mill

A quiet, well appointed room with attentive but not intrusive staff complements a choice of beautifully prepared and presented dishes. The cocktail and wine list is excellent. All in all, a lovely evening.

Fantastic meal and incredible service. The staff were welcoming and wonderful and also helped our table pick out some really excellent wine to pair with our dinner. Don’t sleep on the braised pork cheeks, the fluke tartare, or the sticky date pudding, all so delicious. 10/10.

Food and service was excellent...the mussels are to die for! Really good!

My husband and I ate a lovely dinner here before a show at the Bay Street Theater (btw they offer discount if you show the your tickets!). It was super quiet, there was literally no one in the restaurant for a good hour after we were seated. We ordered a couple of drinks which we enjoyed. The salads were both good and the mains were delicious. I had short ribs and my hubs had filet mignon. We did wait a good bit for our entrees but we had time and the ambience was so nice and relaxing we didn’t mind. By the time we left, the bar below us was getting a bit raucous but again it was not an issue. Just shows people we’re having fun! We decided that we will come next summer and stay the weekend.

Had a terrific meal and experience. My wife, who is a huge fan of crab cakes, said hers were the best she had ever had. Steaks were excellent. Dale was a terrific server!