Best Romantic Restaurants in St Thomas

Beautiful setting. Service was polite but slow. Great food and drinks. Gorgeous beach. The restaurant is part of the Buoy House

Once again, the staff, food and entire experience was amazing at Cutlass and Cane. Came in for Christmas Eve dinner and had Umberto again for our waiter. He was just as great as the last time making us feel welcomed and very happy with our choice. Heather, the GM checked on us and chatted for a bit and definitely added to the wonderful evening.

The service & food was excellent. Love the open air restaurants in St Thomas. This was our first time at the Caribbean Fish Market. My husband had the wahoo & I had the grouper. We shared the salad wedge with shrimp & the coconut cake. EXCELLENT!! The calamari was the best we had ever had at any restaurant. The portions are generous so sharing was a great idea! Definitely recommend to anyone looking to explore restaurants. Remember it’s at the Ritz Carlton Resort. We were staying in Peterborg so I don’t know other restaurants there.

The food was outstanding and so was the service. I only wish we got there earlier to see the beautiful sunset as it was dark but the ambience and the patio was terrific. Highly recommend!

While there was confusion upon arrival with, apparently, our table being occupied (there are very few tables and many/most people are there just for drinks and apps), we wound up with a very nice table. Our plan was to have the Thursday paella-for-2 special and though it was mostly shrimp and mussels and very little of the daily fish and chorizo, it was very tasty. Perfectly moist, flavorful and a good portion. The promotion says it comes with a bottle of wine but it doesn't say, at least then, that you can have any bottle as long as you are choosing the lower priced rose. At the very least normally one would be offered white or red. It wouldn't have been our choice but wasn't bad and certainly, for the locale, good value-for-money. Service was typically indifferent or absent befitting all the F&B properties at the Westin/Buoy Haus but the food and setting made for a decent night. But really, add the word "rose" to the listing to manage expectations if not offering a choice. Note: one white was priced the same and a red was at a $5 higher price-point but maybe they have lots of inventory of the rose and are trying to move it out.