Best Romantic Restaurants in Bayside

Celebrating yet another anniversary in one of the finest restaurants Milwaukee has to offer! This place is the crown Jewel of the Bartolatta family of restaurants. From the staff to the food, simply the best!!!!!

Second time I’ve eaten at Onesto. Still very tasty and enjoyable experience. Love the care and quality put in the food. Good service. Enjoyable ambience. Reasonable prices for the quality. Love that even on the second visit I already had discounts by being in the Loyalty Program.

We had four in our dinner party; 2 first time visitors. My wife and I shared the roasted seafood tower as our entry. Plenty of well prepared seafood items; lobster tails, shrimp (very large), snow crab, scallops and mussles. The broth was a winner too. One of our guests tried the scallops (for the first time) entree that included mushroom risoto. New fan of scallops. Other guest ordered the spicy pasta and enjoyed the preparation. Also ordered some of the specialty drinks. The bar prepared some exquisite drinks.

Our first visit was Xmas eve and it was still very busy, but service was great, now wait for our table and our server was was very attentive. Food was amazing from apps/small plates to main courses. Signature drinks were excellent and creative, even the mocktails were some of the best I have had. Lighting, ambience, and timing of our apps/meal were perfectly timed. We look forward to our next night out at this amazing restaurant.

We love going to Mr B’s It’s a great place but is pricey. The only reason I didn’t give them a 5 on all this time was due to management .. it’s a busy time of year, the place was really busy but they only had one bartender on staff and she was doing her best to keep up, the manager finally stepped in to help and the other staff took some of her tables. We still tipped as we always do but gave the bartender an extra something because she was clearly working hard at both taking orders for food AND bartending.