Best Historic Restaurants in Castleton / Keystone Crossings

It was wonderful. The seafood was amazing. So flavorful and fresh. It is truly as taste of Key West in Central Indiana.

I came here for the first time to celebrate Valentine’s Day. We both enjoyed our food and drinks. The first drink they brought my partner was a specialty V-Day drink that he didn’t care for, but our server quickly removed it and brought out another drink he ordered with no problem. The service was amazing. I. Recommend you try the 16oz ribeye with the mashed potatoes and Brussels sprouts. The crab dip starter was good as well. The whole experience was a 10/10.

Modita always exceeds expectations. The food is top notch, and the menu offerings change periodically. Very attentive service by staff who are incredibly knowledgeable on the menu items. Full service bar rounds out the amazing food.

Enjoyed our visit and food was great and more than we could eat, so now we have lunch for the next day. Kristen was great and offered great suggestions. I had the Schnitzel Cordon Bleu and my wife had the Hot Wurst Plate Appetizer. Oktoberfest Beer was great.

Our New Favorite Spot. Great Service, Excellent Food, Wine List is very reasonably priced. Fried Oysters are amazing. Menu changes often for a wide variety. Definitely be back. Matt (Server) Fantastic.