Best Neighbourhood Gem Restaurants in Bay Shore
Price
- £25 and under
- £26 to £40
- £41 and over
Cuisine
Regions
Areas
Top Rated
Dining Options
Seating options
Accessibility
20 restaurants available nearby
How is content generated
See what locals rave about
- EEVIPNew York City •15 reviews5.0Dined 1 day agoMy friends and I had an exceptional dining experience here, and we were thrilled with every aspect of our meal. The decor and ambiance struck the perfect balance between romantic and classy, creating an inviting atmosphere. We were particularly impressed with the extensive wine list and chose a Napa Valley Cabernet, which was perfect. The food exceeded our expectations, showcasing thoughtful ingredients and masterful preparation. The tomahawk steak, with its beautifully charred exterior and tender, flavorful marbling, was a true standout. We couldn’t resist trying a pasta dish and were delighted by the rigatoni with sausage—perfectly cooked and bursting with flavor. For sides, we shared the creamed spinach and mac and cheese, both of which were incredibly well-executed and far from ordinary. To top it all off, the sugar brownie was the perfect sweet ending to a fantastic meal. Whether you’re planning a night out with friends or looking for the perfect spot for a date, I wholeheartedly recommend this restaurant. It’s a night to remember!More infoPrimi Italian SteakhousePrice: Very Expensive• Italian• West Islip•4.8
- KKennyNew York City •4 reviews5.0Dined 4 days agoEvery time we come here it's a new exceptional experience. Our waitress Stephanie was courteous, professional and friendly she new why we were there and even though we've been here before treated us like if it was our first time here, she was great. Everything overall from our drinks, food and dessert was delicious and greatMore infoTellers: An American ChophousePrice: Very Expensive• Steak• Islip•4.8
- NNancyNew York City •11 reviews5.0Dined 4 days agoAn excellent Sunday Brunch! Our servers were very attentive and friendly. The food, as always, was great; a variety of breakfast, omelettes, carving station, hot foods, salads and desserts.More infoCaptain Bill'sPrice: Expensive• Seafood• Bay Shore•4.7
- KKatieNew York City •7 reviews5.0Dined 5 days agoMy friends & I always enjoy S&B, tonight was no exception! We enjoyed Saturday happy hour (oysters & bubbles), plus delicious burgers. Our server Michael was excellent!More infoSalt and BarrelPrice: Expensive• Contemporary American• Bay Shore•4.7
- BBarbaraVIPGreater Boston •24 reviews5.0Dined on 1 Jan 2025Once again. Delicious. We went for Brunch on New Years. The food was delicious. The only thing i think i would add, is that there are no items outside of the brunch menu available. It is a limited menu so if you are a picky eater, you may want to check out the menu first. But this place remains a favorite, for sure.More infoThe LakehousePrice: Expensive• Contemporary American• Bay Shore•4.7
Discover best neighborhood gem restaurants in Bay Shore
Discover the hidden culinary treasures of Bay Shore, Suffolk in New York State, where each restaurant shines as a neighborhood gem. These dining spots in Bay Shore offer a unique blend of local charm and exceptional cuisine, making them must-visit destinations for both locals and visitors. The dining scene here is vibrant and diverse, featuring establishments that are celebrated for their inviting atmospheres, innovative menus, and commitment to quality. Whether you're craving expertly prepared seafood, artisan cocktails, or a cozy ambiance for a memorable meal, Bay Shore's neighborhood gems have something special to offer. Patrons frequently commend these restaurants for their fantastic food, amazing service, and beautiful decor, ensuring a dining experience that beckons for repeat visits. Each establishment uniquely contributes to the rich culinary tapestry of Bay Shore, making it a prime location for anyone looking to savor great food in a delightful setting.