Enable JavaScript to run this app.
Skip to main content
OpenTable logo
  1. Home
  2. United States
  3. Wisconsin
  4. Milwaukee
  5. Greendale
Joey Gerard's - A Bartolotta Supper Club - Greendale, Greendale, WI

Joey Gerard's - A Bartolotta Supper Club - Greendale

4.4
4.4
3902 Reviews
$30 and under
American

Make a booking

2 people
19:00
Booked 14 times today
  • Good for special occasions
  • Charming
  • Neighbourhood gem
Joey Gerard's - A Bartolotta Supper Club is located in the charming village of historic Greendale. Opened in August of 2012, Joey Gerard's pays homage to Joe Bartolotta's childhood and the supper clubs he frequented with his parents growing up. Midwest supper clubs were born in the early 1930s mostly in rural Wisconsin and became an enticing destination where people would gather for cocktails, supper, and entertainment. Neighborhood camaraderie and a comfortable atmosphere is a commonality all supper clubs hold to this day.
The vibe at Joey Gerard’s embraces a casual dining experience. Combining classic supper club menu options, a great steak selection, classic cocktails and ice cream drinks make Joey Gerard’s the perfect gathering place.

Reservations are recommended, and we have a 15-minute grace period, so please call us if you are running late.

Additional information

  • Dining style
    Casual Elegant
  • Price
    $30 and under
  • Cuisines
    American, Steak, Seafood
  • Hours of Operation
    Mon–Sat 17:00–21:00 Happy Hour Mon–Fri 16:00–18:00
  • Phone number
    (414) 858-1900
  • Website
    http://www.joeygerards.com/
  • Payment Options
    AMEX, Carte Blanche, Diners Club, Discover, Mastercard, Visa
  • Dress code
    Casual Dress
  • Executive Chef
    Connor McNeil
  • Private party facilities
    Take a step back in time at Joey Gerard's in the village of Greendale. Featuring a wide variety of steaks, seafood, and sandwiches plus classic cocktails and value-driven beer and wine, Joey Gerard's offers menus and spaces to cater to every occasion. The location offers several different room options, from the intimate Reiman Room to the Skylight Room. In addition to the extensive, delicious food offerings, the setting at Joey Gerard's will have your guests feeling comfortable and relaxed. Dark leather booths, period light fixtures and black and white photos of celebrities enjoying the supper club experience in the 40s and 50s paired with Bartolotta's high level of service create a warm, welcoming atmosphere.
  • Location
    5601 Broad Street, Greendale, WI 53129
  • Area
    Greendale
  • Cross Street
    Northway
  • Parking details
    Please park in the public lots in front of and behind the building.
  • Additional
    Banquet, Bar/Lounge, Beer, Cocktails, Full Bar, Gluten-free Options, Happy Hour, Indoor Fireplace, Non-Smoking, Private Room, Wheelchair Access, Wine

Featured in

Menu

House-Made Desserts

  • Schaum TorteUS$11.00

    Our version of the classic: light meringue vanilla ice cream, whipped chantilly cream, macerated strawberries

    • Cherries Jubilee CheesecakeUS$10.00

      New York-style cheesecake, topped with Kirschwasser cherry and whipped cream

      • Crème BrûléeUS$11.00

        Bartolotta's classic vanilla bean-baked custard with a caramelized sugar crust

        • Chocolate Lava CakeUS$12.00

          A rich house-made chocolate cake, molten fudge center, raspberry coulis, vanilla bean ice cream

          • Joey's Ice Cream Sundae for TwoUS$14.00

            Vanilla bean ice cream, topped with hot fudge, caramel sauce, praline blondie fudge brownies, fresh whipped chantilly cream, cherry

            Ice Cream Drinks

            • Brandy AlexanderUS$13.00

              Brandy, créme de cacao, ice cream

              • GrasshopperUS$13.00

                Crème de menthe, créme de cacao, ice cream

                • Pal JoeyUS$13.00

                  Coffee Liqueur, Irish Cream, Amaretto, Crème de Cocoa, Ice Cream

                  • Pink SquirrelUS$13.00

                    Crème de Cacao, Crème de Noyaux, Vanilla Ice cream, Topped with Whipped Cream and a Cherry

                    Last updated: 25 April 2024

                    What 3,902 people are saying

                    Overall ratings and reviews

                    Reviews can only be made by diners who have eaten at this restaurant

                    4.4
                    4.4 based on recent ratings
                    • 4.4Food
                    • 4.6Service
                    • 4.6Ambience
                    • 4.1Value

                    Noise • Moderate

                    Review summary

                    AI-generated from verified diner reviews
                    Joey Gerard's offers an "absolutely wonderful experience" with "top quality food" and "extremely great service." Diners rave about the "delicious meal" and "friendly staff," with many highlighting specific dishes like "excellent lamb chops" and "tender filet mignon." The "great atmosphere" and "supper club vibe" contribute to a memorable dining experience.

                    3,902 Reviews

                    1. Gregory

                      Milwaukee

                      25 reviews

                      2.0

                      25 reviews

                      Dined 1 day ago

                      1. Overall 2
                      2. Food 1
                      3. Service 4
                      4. Ambience 2
                      Joey’s was not up to the level that I expect from a Bartelotta restaurant. It started out with a very mediocre martini topped with a canned olive not the big brined olives that you get in other restaurants. Them wife’s steak was over charred and very tough. A nice char on a steak is delicious but this was extreme. Finally my walleye had almost no seasoning or flavor and was overcooked and dry. This is probably the only Bartelotta restaurant that I have given a bad review.

                      Is this helpful?

                    2. Jesse

                      Milwaukee

                      1 review

                      5.0

                      1 review

                      Dined 2 days ago

                      1. Overall 5
                      2. Food 5
                      3. Service 5
                      4. Ambience 5
                      First time going! And on Valentine’s Day! Excellent service and the filet mignon was cooked perfectly would come again!

                      Is this helpful?

                    3. Jake

                      San Francisco

                      2 reviews

                      3.0

                      2 reviews

                      Dined 2 days ago

                      1. Overall 3
                      2. Food 3
                      3. Service 3
                      4. Ambience 3
                      Made Valentines reservations for 7, showed up 5 minutes early, and then had to wait to be seated until 7:35. No music was on in the restaurant which made the vibe a little awkward. My wife is pregnant, so we tried some mocktails. The hibiscus wasn’t very well thought out. So much stuff floating around in the drink that it couldn’t be drunk through a straw. She had the honey mustard salmon. It was very sweet and a strange flavor profile for salmon. I had the walleye pike special. The fish was extremely bland and needed lots of lemon and salt to make it flavorful. Overall, we expected a bit more from a Bartolotta restaurant, especially for the premium pricing.

                      Is this helpful?

                    4. Jacob

                      Milwaukee

                      1 review

                      3.0

                      1 review

                      Dined 2 days ago

                      1. Overall 3
                      2. Food 4
                      3. Service 2
                      4. Ambience 5
                      The food, drinks and wait staff were great but we waited almost an hour after our reservation time that I paid $50 in advance. I know the wifi was down but reservations have been around longer than wifi.

                      Is this helpful?

                    5. Bishop

                      Columbus

                      9 reviews

                      4.0

                      9 reviews

                      Dined 2 days ago

                      1. Overall 4
                      2. Food 5
                      3. Service 3
                      4. Ambience 4
                      Over booked and under staffed. Waited nearly 20 minutes for our reserved table. Then waited more than 5 minutes (almost 10) before our server came with water. Tiniest table for 2 I have ever sat at. Great place, but I won’t be returning any time soon.

                      Is this helpful?

                    6. Anthony

                      Milwaukee

                      3 reviews

                      1.0

                      3 reviews

                      Dined 2 days ago

                      1. Overall 1
                      2. Food 1
                      3. Service 2
                      4. Ambience 2
                      Was not impressed for the money/cost. Food was average at best and just not with the money. Won’t be back.

                      Is this helpful?

                    7. Lynn

                      Milwaukee

                      6 reviews

                      4.0

                      6 reviews

                      Dined 2 days ago

                      1. Overall 4
                      2. Food 5
                      3. Service 5
                      4. Ambience 5
                      Steak was exceptional as was the raspberry tiramisu. The scallops were good but needed a little more coloring/ garnish in the way of vegetables. Our waitress Carly was exceptional. Give her a raise!

                      Is this helpful?

                    8. fernando

                      Milwaukee

                      1 review

                      4.0

                      1 review

                      Dined 3 days ago

                      1. Overall 4
                      2. Food 3
                      3. Service 5
                      4. Ambience 5
                      Overall very good. My only complaint is that both of our steaks were overcooked. They were still ok but I would not order a steak if I returned. The rest of the food was delicious.

                      Is this helpful?

                    9. Milan

                      Milwaukee

                      12 reviews

                      5.0

                      12 reviews

                      Dined 3 days ago

                      1. Overall 5
                      2. Food 5
                      3. Service 5
                      4. Ambience 5
                      1st time there and we enjoyed the ambience, decorated well and had the vibe of a high end Supper Club, minus the salad bar which is fine with me. Sophie was our server and she was great, very “bubbly” personality, attentive and knew what she was doing. My wife had the tenderloin and I had the double lamb chops, both done as ordered and to perfection. Everything was at proper temperature, fresh and delicious. We had Crème brûlée for dessert! yum! I had the Argentinian cocktail which i had never had that bourbon version, it was delicious! We will be coming back for sure and suggest you try it!

                      Is this helpful?

                    10. Chris

                      Milwaukee

                      3 reviews

                      4.0

                      3 reviews

                      Dined 3 days ago

                      1. Overall 4
                      2. Food 4
                      3. Service 5
                      4. Ambience 5
                      The ambiance and service were great. One of our steaks was significantly over-cooked but was ok. Overall it was a good meal.

                      Is this helpful?

                    FAQs

                    Joey Gerard's - A Bartolotta Supper Club - Greendale is rated 4.4 stars by 3902 OpenTable diners.

                    Yes, you can generally book this restaurant by choosing the date, time and party size on OpenTable.

                    Make a booking

                    2 people
                    19:00
                    Booked 14 times today
                    Google Map for Joey Gerard's - A Bartolotta Supper Club - Greendale

                    5601 Broad Street, Greendale, WI 53129

                    Additional information

                    • Cross Street
                      Northway
                    • Area
                      Greendale
                    • Hours of Operation
                      Mon–Sat 17:00–21:00 Happy Hour Mon–Fri 16:00–18:00
                    • Price
                      $30 and under
                    • Cuisines
                      American, Steak, Seafood
                    • Dining style
                      Casual Elegant
                    • Dress code
                      Casual Dress
                    • Parking details
                      Please park in the public lots in front of and behind the building.
                    • Payment Options
                      AMEX, Carte Blanche, Diners Club, Discover, Mastercard, Visa
                    • Executive Chef
                      Connor McNeil
                    • Additional
                      Banquet, Bar/Lounge, Beer, Cocktails, Full Bar, Gluten-free Options, Happy Hour, Indoor Fireplace, Non-Smoking, Private Room, Wheelchair Access, Wine
                    • Website
                      http://www.joeygerards.com/
                    • Phone number
                      (414) 858-1900
                    • Private party facilities
                      Take a step back in time at Joey Gerard's in the village of Greendale. Featuring a wide variety of steaks, seafood, and sandwiches plus classic cocktails and value-driven beer and wine, Joey Gerard's offers menus and spaces to cater to every occasion. The location offers several different room options, from the intimate Reiman Room to the Skylight Room. In addition to the extensive, delicious food offerings, the setting at Joey Gerard's will have your guests feeling comfortable and relaxed. Dark leather booths, period light fixtures and black and white photos of celebrities enjoying the supper club experience in the 40s and 50s paired with Bartolotta's high level of service create a warm, welcoming atmosphere.

                    Featured in

                    Discover
                    OpenTable
                    • About Us
                    • Blog
                    • Careers
                    • Press
                    More
                    Our sites
                    Businesses
                    • Delight more diners
                    • Restaurant Blog
                    Join us on
                    • Privacy Policy
                    • Terms of Use
                    • Impressum
                    • Cookies and Interest-Based Ads
                    • Cookie Preferences
                    Copyright © 2024 OpenTable International Ltd. Alphabeta Building, 14-18 Finsbury Square, London EC2A 1AH - All rights reserved.
                    OpenTable is part of Booking Holdings, the world leader in online travel and related services.
                    Booking Logo
                    Priceline Logo
                    KAYAK Logo
                    Agoda Logo
                    OpenTable Logo