Restaurants near Athenaeum Theatre

It was our first time at Santa Baby, we thought it was nicely decorated. It gets very busy, I would recommend reservations especially if you don’t live close. The food is like typical bar food, but you’re paying for the experience. Overall we had a good time. They had Christmas movie trivia which was fun and they had some great prizes!!

Service was great and food was very good. The table we were sat at as a party of 5 was very tight. Kids enjoyed making pizzas.

We came over to check in about 15 mins before our reservations and we were seared immediately. Everyone was so friendly and polite. The place was decorated beautifully. We love the fairies that come around to the table no matter how old you are. They were so sweet and make the experience even more enjoyable. Our waiter was wonderful so attentive, never having to look for him, always refilling our glasses and providing prompt and friendly service. Food came out quick and was very good. We never felt rushed. We were able to go by the tree and take pictures. It was just a fabulous time. We had our first experience there last year and now we’ve made this an annual tradition. We look forward to many more years to come.

It was a wonderful food experience! Everything we had was amazing and we will definitely be back!

From the moment one walks in, it’s clear this restaurant has mastered the art of hospitality. The food is consistently exceptional—outstanding, in fact. Whether it’s the chicken Vesuvius, the delicate pasta, or the homemade desserts, every plate is bursting with flavor. What really sets this place apart, though, is the service. It’s impeccable. The waitstaff is not only attentive, but also genuinely friendly. They're always happy to offer recommendations, and their knowledge of the menu is impressive. This place is the perfect combination of great food and outstanding service, creating an unforgettable dining experience every time.