Restaurants near Colgate Lake

Beautiful restaurant. Food and service were on point!

I always enjoy this restaurant. It is constantly a great place to dine whether it is just 2 or a large party.

The Phoenician Steakhouse is our go-to spot when we are in the Catskills. The service is consistently friendly and the food reliably delicious. The owner, Mike, can often be seen in the kitchen cooking and overseeing the food preparation. We have our favorite dishes — the beet salad and panko crusted mozzarella, and the steaks, pappardelle bolognese and osso bucco ravioli. And of course the tiramisu. But any new thing we try such as last night’s squash soup and clam chowder, are also winners. In the summer we love sitting on the back patio.

Had a lovely time! It's a pretty place. Warm and inviting and the food was good.

This has to be the best restaurant in Tannersville/Hunter. The food is incredibly fresh, innovative and thoroughly enjoyable. We had the veal parm (which was not your ordinary veal parm)....on the bone and shareable. Absolutely delicious. The french onion soup -- nothing comes close ... the artichoke salad and Caesar where perfection. Of course the octopus was as delicious as always. Highly recommend -- I can't leave without mentioning the awesome drinks ... Winter Warmth (a cinnamon margarita) is hard to explain how good it was.