Restaurants near Stillwater Prairie Reserve

We had a wonderful girls night out! Our waitress Gabby was amazing and SO helpful. She absolutely made our experience, it was my first time visiting and she helped me understand what I wanted and also helped me sign up to be a wine club member. She sold me on the membership without being pushy about it and sent me home with my first two bottles same night. I can’t wait to come back with my husband for a date night, we will absolutely be asking for Gabby every time we come! The food was SO delicious, I had the burger and my date had the chicken both were wonderful and the little truffles were a perfect finish. It was nice to have a little sweet treat option that wasn’t huge after a big meal. The vibes and lighting were calm and sophisticated and the whole staff was very friendly. I felt that the pricing was justified for the experience you get. The only thing I would have changed is that I wish if you book a reservation that you would have a guaranteed availability for a wine tasting. We made reservations for 8:30 and we arrived at 7:30 to do a wine tasting before dinner but it was so packed that we didn’t get to partake. It was a bit awkward to stand there trying to find a spot to squeeze into so we gave up on it and went back out to the car to wait for our dinner reservation. What a great “problem” to have though as a business! Even with the slight hiccup on the wine tasting part of the night, I would absolutely give an overall 10/10 5 stars and beyond!!

The food was tremendous as always, service was very attentive and timely. And there was a mix-up from the local florist to deliver flowers for my wife's birthday and Silas went out and got flowers and brought them to our table before the end of the meal thank you, Samantha. Craig and Susie

I met my niece and her husband at Coldwater Cafe for dinner. It was midway geographically from both of us, but the real reason was I had had lunch there with a friend a few times and really loved it. I wanted to try dinner there. The atmosphere was great. The food was spectacular! We all got something different and none of us were disappointed. The wine was also great and the desserts were wonderful. We will be back there. Thanks!

We had late notification on menu change but, the personal attention from the dtaff more than made up for that.

Always happy here!