Keuka Lake Restaurants

Delicious food! One of the best places in the village. Connor is awesome-so friendly and personable!

As usual, the food was outstanding. I got the 16oz. prime rib which was perfectly cooked. The server, Faith, was wonderful and polite. She did a great job making sure everything was to our liking. The owners Deborah and John are always friendly and ask us how our meals were making sure we were satisfied. Thank you again for a great experience!

Kortney is literally the best server i’ve ever had ! She made us feel so welcome, gave great recommendations and checked in to make sure everything was going okay. will always ask for her when we come in !

Great Experience for the holiday. Would return for the holiday in the future. Did happen to notice a table did get up and leave due to not being served in a timely manor. This happened to us years ago there but after this years experience they have redeemed themselves and we will plan to visit again.

We have never had a bad meal at Nolan’s. We eat there 5-6 times annually. It’s a favorite for our special nights out. Last night was equally favorable with great service, a cozy ambience as we sat near the fireplace and a delicious and beautifully prepared meal. Our only concern (a first) was that the food was not served as hot as we anticipated. It was not cold or luke warm but not hot enough to last most of the meal. We did share that information with the waitress after the meal was over. We’ll absolutely return. It’s a well run establishment that provides a great dining experience.