Caledonia Restaurants

Always a pleasurable experience! Food was fantastic! The Kegnog is outstanding! Our server was Larenz. He was excellent. Very friendly and attentive 😊

We made a reservation for the table beside the fireplace In The bar for ambience and because it is tradition. I made the reservation over a month in advance and when we got there the entire restaurant was almost completely empty and when the waitress went to seat us, there was a computer on the table we requested. She said just a second and went and checked why. Turns out the manager decided to use that table to do work. They offered for us to sit next to it, but we declined because I don’t feel like eating a $300 dinner sitting beside someone who’s doing work on a computer. We ended up taking a booth off to the side. I’m a creature of habit and that is why I requested that exact table months in advance. It was disappointing and threw off the entire night. Food was amazing and our waitress was very good and she got a big tip.

We thoroughly enjoyed our brunch at the Mill. The historic buildings, both inside and out, are gorgeous. And the food! It was a pleasure to have an expansive buffet offered. Everything was presented in a charming yet elegant way. The seafood (freshly shucked oysters, large shrimp, smoked salmon, mussels, crab legs), and plenty of it, was a highlight for us. But the carvery station with baked ham and roast beef and roast pork with old-fashioned crackling was equally yummy! The service and attention to detail really shine. And a big part of that was due to our server, Candace. She was simply wonderful. Thank you all. Our 50th wedding anniversary tour continues, but this was a highlight.

Food was delicious and service was exceptional. All our steaks were cooked perfectly and there was a variety of side options to meet everyone’s tastes at the table. Lovely family dinner.