Put-in-Bay Restaurants

This was our first time to Crush in Sandusky, OH and it was absolutely phenomenal. The service by Marissa was exemplary and all of the food and drink was excellent. The atmosphere for Valentine's Day was perfect and we cannot wait to return. Thank you so much for a wonderful evening!

Excellent steak and pasta at The Club highly suggest! Side of carrots are excellent surprise and house salad and cocktails excellent!

Four of us went for a 1:30 reservation on Valentine’s Day. At that time it was not crowded, we were not rushed; it was a very leisurely lunch. Our server was professional knowledgeable. I look forward to another visit. We ordered from the lunch menu, 2 of us ordered smash burgers, another a salad with chicken topping, and I had the flat iron steak. We were all pleased. The truffle fries were delicious. And the extra salad I ordered to go with the steak and fries was just the right size, perfectly dressed. The cocktails 2 of us had were exceptional. I had a pear martini with sage simple syrup (not sure if that’s how it was described) and my friend had the fig and vanilla martini. We were both happy!

Our family throughly enjoyed our dining experience at Sortino’s. The portions were large, and the food was delicious. The Chicken Parmesan was among the best my husband has ever had. The service was excellent, and the owner even stopped by our table to ensure we were having an excellent experience. Highly recommended.

A very sad night with the closing of Bay Habor for the season. This restaurant has been a year-round "go to" for our family for 35 plus years, now silenced by Cedar Fair. 25-year employees out of a job just before the Holidays.