Best Date Night Restaurants in Amityville

From the moment we walked in to walking out, it was a home run. We sat a few minutes before our reservation and had a server within minutes and drinks soon afterwards. Multiple staff took care of us to ensure we had food and anything we needed. The food was great and the cost was reasonable. A great experience and we will go back soon.

We had a very nice Valentine Day dinner off the special menu. We had the Oysters Rockerfeller, they were not traditional but very good. The heart shaped ravioli were delicious. The mains were lobster tails and steak au povire. The mains were very good, I just wish the steak was a tad more tender. Portions were generous and we took some home. Our waitress was fabulous. Great place.

There were four of us and we each had a different fish dish. We are in the clean plate club! The fish was cooked perfectly and was so delicious. I can’t wait to have the swordfish again. Our server, Dave was friendly, helpful and efficient and made our experience special. The only negative was that it was extremely noisy with every table full and as the servers rearranged chairs to make room at the tables, they dragged the chairs and tables across the floor. The noise was really jarring and had all of us on edge. We will definitely be back but hope that more care is taken when setting up tables in a crowded and noisy space.

I took my wife there for our anniversary dinner. The atmosphere was unbelievable. Our waiter David was such a pleasure to chat with. He was professional, courteous, and pleasant to deal with. The food from start to finish was exceptional. We started out with a margarita flatbread pizza with Barata on top Then I had the Parmesan vodka chicken with spicy rigatoni and my wife had the roasted chicken with vegetables. For dessert, we shared the tartufo.. The overall dining experience was such a pleasure. We will be going back many times over. If you have the chance to visit this exquisite restaurant, please do.

All good except they asked us to be finished by a certain time to seat another party. I think it was unnecessary to ask that. We were done in plenty of time