Best Restaurants with a Tasting Menu in Plaza / Brookside

We brought my best friend and her husband from Indianapolis and they were blown away. They finished their meal and said they wish there was a Lydia's in the Indianapolis area. Consistently absolutely delicious food, impeccable service and ambiance. Can't beat this! Recommend that reservations are made in advance because this is a VERY popular place.

Beautiful restaurant with great service and ambiance. The food was good with great presentation, but a little on the pricey side. It made for a great date night. We were both very impressed.

Amazing experience tonight. Fred, is a great server and was impeccable. Can’t wait for next meal. 10stars

We go to Story at least every month and we love everything about this place! The food is excellent and especially the soft shell crab when in season, just delicious. We have taken many friends there for dinner and they come back every time with us .

Pretty pricey but extremely good, you definitely get what you pay for and the staff was professional and proficient. They had knowledge on all aspects of the menu and checked on us the exact right amount of times so we lacked nothing but never felt as though they were hovering. Awesome experience.