Best Italian Restaurants in Bainbridge Island

37 restaurants available nearby

1. The Pink Door

4.8

Exceptional(8847)

Price: Very Expensive

• Italian • Belltown / Pike Place Market

Booked 149 times today

The Pink Door is an independently owned (never cloned, never genetically modified) restaurant that has been quietly dedicated to fresh & local Italian food since 1981. Its seafood & produce driven menu has been the central theme throughout its wildly popular domain in Seattle's Pike Place Market.

2. San Fermo

4.8

Exceptional(1601)

Price: Very Expensive

• Italian • Ballard / Fremont

Booked 53 times today

We have 15 indoor tables, and 12 covered/heated patio tables. Online reservations can be made for parties up to 5 guests. Larger groups can be booked at 5pm on weeknights, please email the restaurant for reservations. Please understand when making your reservation that we cannot guarantee a specific table or area of the restaurant. We recommend 5pm reservations for parties with specific table requests, if you book later in the evening you may need to wait for your table preference.If you are having difficulty finding a reservation you are welcome to stop by for walk-in seating. We seat our bar and covered/heated patio for dinner nightly.

A photo of Mondello Ristorante Italiano restaurant

3. Mondello Ristorante Italiano

4.9

Exceptional(469)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Magnolia

Booked 3 times today

Mondello Italian Restaurant in the beautiful Seattle neighborhood of Magnolia provides one of the most romantic, most authentic Italian dining experiences in Seattle. Mondello has beautiful pasta dishes, seafood & main courses, salads, zuppe & bruschette & antipasti dishes. Corino (owner) & Enza (chef) grew up in the vicinity of Mondello and they bring to Seattle their wonderful tradition of fresh seafood, homemade pasta & rich authentic Sicilian cuisine with all it's flair & joy of living. They have the life experience of fine cooking and appreciation & sensiblity of the Italian palate that allows them to create a dining experience reminiscent of being in Mondello, Sicily. No one fails to be entranced by Mondello's welcoming beauty and warm personality.Grazie Amici!

4. Stoneburner

4.8

Exceptional(1681)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Ballard / Fremont

Booked 46 times today

At Stoneburner, located in the vibrant Ballard neighborhood of Seattle, the pizzeria cuisine is a standout, crafting pizzas that are a true homage to the Mediterranean while celebrating the Pacific Northwest's natural bounty. The stone hearth cooking method brings out the robust flavors in every dish, particularly their pizzas. Guests consistently rave about the quality, with one diner noting, "The pizza and cocktails were well crafted and delicious. The ingredients were very high quality." Another echoed this sentiment, saying the pepperoni pizza was "highly recommend and will be back." Stoneburner not only delivers on exceptional taste but also creates a warm, inviting atmosphere that complements its high-quality dishes, making it a must-visit for both locals and visitors alike.

5. Messina

4.1

Excellent(236)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Queen Anne

Booked 65 times today

Messina Modern Italian Kitchen in the vibrant Queen Anne neighborhood of Seattle is a treasure trove of contemporary Italian fare infused with Pacific Northwest flair. Right next to the Climate Pledge Arena, it’s the perfect spot for an exceptional dining experience whether for a family dinner, a romantic date, or before a game. Guests rave about the creative dishes like the "spicy pepperoni pizza which was 🔥" and the "pasta board which is a whole vibe!" The service is consistently praised, with one reviewer exclaiming, "Truly one of the best dining experiences I’ve had in Seattle." Messina also delights with its inventive drinks and desserts, notably the "pistachio cannoli" and handcrafted cocktails. It’s clear that Messina’s blend of traditional Italian elements with modern twists and excellent service makes it a must-visit destination.

6. Spinasse

4.8

Exceptional(3780)

Price: Very Expensive

• Italian • Capitol Hill / First Hill

Booked 36 times today

Spinasse in Seattle's vibrant Capitol Hill / First Hill neighborhood stands as a beacon of Italian culinary excellence. Renowned for its handcrafted pastas, such as the "simply outstanding" Tarjin and "heavenly" butter sage pasta, this restaurant ensures a memorable dining experience with every dish. Visitors rave about the delicate, perfectly prepared pasta, describing it as "a spiritual experience" and "the best pasta you will ever taste." Spinasse's atmosphere is equally praised, offering a warm, inviting setting that complements its exquisite Piedmont-inspired menu. Whether it's the "amazing" service or the "incredible" food, Spinasse consistently delivers an enchanting taste of Italy, making it a must-visit destination for both locals and tourists alike.

A photo of Il Terrazzo Carmine restaurant

7. Il Terrazzo Carmine

4.8

Exceptional(4056)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Pioneer Square

Booked 44 times today

Il Terrazzo Carmine, owned and operated by Carmine Smeraldo, is one of Seattle's true dining anomalies - a highly successful restaurant with unfailingly high standards and a loyal, sophisticated clientele. The cuisine has been acclaimed as Seattle's best by the media and more importantly, by local diners. Il Terrazzo Carmine is located in historic Pioneer Square - nestled in an urban-renewed alley with entrances through the vintage lobby on First Avenue or through the delightful courtyard in the back. Since 1984, Carmine Smeraldo's classic Italian restaurant has been where the locals have chosen to return over and over again. From the Carpaccio Di Bue and Spaghettini Dell 'Ortolano for lunch to the Suprema Di Pollo Farcita and Zuppa Di Pesce for dinner you will know you have gone to a place where excellence is a way of life. Arguably the best Italian restaurant in Seattle, Il Terrazzo serves classical Italian cuisine with an atmosphere you may want to call home and never leave

A photo of La Fontana Siciliana restaurant

8. La Fontana Siciliana

4.8

Exceptional(1675)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Belltown / Pike Place Market

Booked 26 times today

Nestled in Seattle's vibrant Belltown, La Fontana Siciliana offers an enchanting slice of Sicily, promising an authentic Italian dining experience. The restaurant's dedication to authenticity and quality shines through in dishes crafted from locally sourced ingredients, meticulously prepared under the guidance of Chef Antonio Torralba. Guests rave about the "super authentic, great food" and highlight the Risotto ai Marsala and Pollo Marsala as must-tries. The secluded courtyard setting enhances the experience, making every meal feel like a special occasion. Reviewers consistently praise the atmosphere and service, describing the experience as "wonderful" and "unforgettable." Whether you're celebrating a special event or seeking a memorable meal, La Fontana Siciliana delivers an exceptional blend of Sicilian hospitality and culinary excellence.

A photo of Artusi (21 and over) restaurant

9. Artusi (21 and over)

4.7

Exceptional(74)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Capitol Hill / First Hill

Booked 8 times today

Artusi is 21 and olderCome enjoy our pasta and wine night on Sunday and Monday, and Industry night on Tuesday with 10% off. Chef Stuart Lane creates a casual menu offering including our multi award winning meatballs. We only accept reservations for parties of 3 or more, we encourage parties of 1 or 2 to walk in! On Sunday/Monday night, we do not accept any reservations and operate just on a walk in basis.

10. Grappa - Seattle

4.7

Exceptional(1195)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Queen Anne

Booked 33 times today

Nestled in the vibrant Queen Anne neighborhood of Seattle, Grappa shines as a beacon of authentic Italian cuisine. Celebrated for its "consistently delicious food" and a "great bar program," Grappa offers an experience that keeps locals and visitors coming back. Diners rave about dishes like the seafood risotto and bolognese, praising their "properly cooked seafood" and the "delicious" sauces that accompany them. The ambiance is described as "intimate," perfect for enjoying "one of the best meals" with crafted cocktails and an extended wine list. With its commitment to excellent service and sumptuous small plates, Grappa stands out as a must-visit for a genuine taste of Italy in Seattle.

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

See what locals rave about

From verified diners like you

A
Anne
Seattle / Eastern Washington •4 reviews
5.0
Dined today
Such a lovely night and dining experience all the way around. Food and drinks were absolutely exceptional. Service - wonderful: attentive but not intrusive. Ambiance…lovely, but just a bit chilly by the front door. Looking forward to returning soon.
More info
SpinassePrice: Very Expensive• Italian• Capitol Hill / First Hill
•
4.8
S
senait
Seattle / Eastern Washington •1 review
5.0
Dined 1 day ago
Hands down the best restaurant I’ve been to in such a long time. The atmosphere, the staff is magnificent as well as the flood. This was a 10/10 experience and would definitely recommend and try to again as well.
More info
La Fontana SicilianaPrice: Expensive• Italian• Belltown / Pike Place Market
•
4.8
J
Judith
Seattle / Eastern Washington •1 review
5.0
Dined 2 days ago
This is one legendary restaurant that lives up to its legend. The food is out of this world. The service is brilliant. The room with a view is spectacular and the room in the lounge is cozy. This is a go-to place for special occasions. Thank you to Jackie, Jeannie and the whole staff who greeted us and our special guest so warmly.
More info
The Pink DoorPrice: Very Expensive• Italian• Belltown / Pike Place Market
•
4.8
C
Connie
Idaho •1 review
5.0
Dined 2 days ago
As always the food and service was outstanding. Lunch and dinner are both excellent choices
More info
Il Terrazzo CarminePrice: Expensive• Italian• Pioneer Square
•
4.8
K
Katya
Seattle / Eastern Washington •4 reviews
5.0
Dined 3 days ago
The ambiance and service were outstanding. The menu is well-developed and interesting. Some of the food like the burrata appetizer and the bolognese was excellent. We found the mushroom risotto and the beef short rib to be overly salty. Great drinks as well!
More info
San FermoPrice: Very Expensive• Italian• Ballard / Fremont
•
4.8

Explore OpenTable

Bainbridge Island

Italian

Best Italian Restaurants in Bainbridge Island

Price

Regions

Areas

Top Rated

Dining Options

Seating options

Accessibility

37 restaurants available nearby

1. The Pink Door

2. San Fermo

3. Mondello Ristorante Italiano

4. Stoneburner

5. Messina

6. Spinasse

7. Il Terrazzo Carmine

8. La Fontana Siciliana

9. Artusi (21 and over)

10. Grappa - Seattle

See what locals rave about

Explore OpenTable