Best Seafood Restaurants in Amelia Island
Price
Regions
Areas
Top Rated
Dining Options
Seating options
Accessibility
7 restaurants available nearby
How is content generated
See what locals rave about
- MMichelleVIPNashville •19 reviews4.0Dined 1 day agoThe selling point is the service. The ambiance is nice. The dining area is loud, but the tables are spaced such that you can hear those at your table. I ordered the 14 oz ribeye for $65. This is a value because it comes with a giant carrot (has to be GMO) with special glaze and a choice of potato (baked, smashed, skillet fried potatoes topped with onions and gravy, sweet potato, or fries). The problem was that the ribeye came out and it looked like a thin New York strip full of gristle. It was the most disappointing steak that I’ve had in a very long time. I expect a ribeye to have marbling, but not gristle. To the server’s credit she took the entire meal off of my check. I declined a replacement entree because my dinner companions were already finished with their meals, I was traveling the next day, and leftovers would not work for me. I would have accepted a compensatory dessert, but they did not have any gluten free options other than crème brûlée. My dinner companions are local residents. They love the shrimp pasta dish, the crab cakes, and Caesar salad (lightly tossed) are their favorites. But, after my steak mishap, they remembered that another visitor had a horrible experience when ordering a ribeye. He thought it was a one off incident, but now suspects that Bob’s just does not have a good ribeye. He said that when the visitor ordered the 28 oz porterhouse steak the next visit that it was wonderful. While I appreciate that the server took care of my meal, I did not like it that she tried to counsel me that ribeyes often are fatty with gristle and that I should order the filet next time. I did not bother to argue the absurdity of her point. Overall, I would definitely try Bob’s again to order a steak other than the ribeye.More infoBob’s Steak & Chop House – Amelia IslandPrice: Expensive• Steakhouse• Amelia Island•4.7
- SScottLas Vegas •1 review5.0Dined 3 days agogreat food good service would definitely go back againMore infoCoast at The Ritz-CarltonPrice: Moderate• Seafood• Amelia Island•4.3
- CCrystalAtlanta •14 reviews4.0Dined 3 days agoGreat service, great food. A wonderful gem in Fernandina.More infoCucina SouthPrice: Expensive• Italian• Fernandina Beach•4.6
- DdennisJacksonville / Northeast Florida •37 reviews5.0Dined 4 days agoExcellent service Excellent food Very good ambienceMore infoDavid's Restaurant & LoungePrice: Expensive• Steakhouse• Fernandina Beach•4.7
- WWilliamVIPSan Francisco Bay Area •23 reviews5.0Dined on 3 Mar 2025We ate on the lovely, quiet patio Our server, Jill, was top-notch: pleasant, attentive and efficient. Best of all, the food was superb! Wish we lived nearby because we'd be there regularly.More infoBurlingamePrice: Expensive• Contemporary American• Fernandina Beach•4.8
Discover best Seafood restaurants in Amelia Island
Discover the delights of Amelia Island's seafood scene, where every restaurant offers a unique taste of the ocean's bounty. Renowned for its fresh, locally-sourced seafood, Amelia Island, located in Northeast Florida, is a paradise for seafood enthusiasts. From succulent scallops and light, crispy calamari to perfectly cooked swordfish, the range of seafood available reflects the region's rich maritime heritage and commitment to quality. The dining atmosphere across these establishments varies from invitingly casual to innovatively coastal, each creating a memorable experience that complements the scenic views of the northeastern Florida coast. Patrons consistently praise the excellent seafood, describing dishes as fresh, flavorful, and artistically presented. Beyond the exceptional food, reviews highlight the impeccable service and the relaxing, enjoyable ambiance that enhances dining experiences. Whether you're a local or a visitor, exploring Amelia Island's seafood restaurants is a must for an authentic taste of what the region has to offer. Each establishment not only promises a delightful culinary journey but also contributes to a vibrant dining scene known for its quality and hospitality.