Best American Restaurants in Shelter Island
Price
Regions
Areas
Top Rated
Dining Options
Seating options
Accessibility
8 restaurants available nearby
How is content generated
See what locals rave about
- HhamptonsmamaVIPSouthwest Florida •15 reviews5.0Dined 3 days agoAlways great food, service was superb thanks Eden!More infoVine Street CafePrice: Very Expensive• American• Shelter Island•4.7
- SstephenVIPNew York City •5 reviews5.0Dined 3 days agoLovely as always, food and service top notch. A consistent gem.More infoThe North Fork Table & InnPrice: Very Expensive• Contemporary American• Southold•4.5
- NNickNew York City •3 reviews5.0Dined 6 days agoHello , Our experience with team from the Haylard and Sparkling point was Fun and Informative. We learned alot about the Maillard effect and the great pairing between champagne and sparkling wines with browned and roasted foods . The food was Outstanding . The view of the sound and overall ambiance of the restaurant is always Superb . Looking forward to more of these educational pairings . Thanks for a new experience. Nick Main Street FireplaceMore infoThe Halyard Restaurant at Sound ViewPrice: Expensive• American• Greenport•4.4
- CCarol ZimmerNew York City •8 reviews4.0Dined on 14 Feb 2025Delicious halibut special entree, and scrumptious crab cake app w-salsa. Great food, local vibe, always a great time.More infoSophie's Rest.Price: Moderate• American• Southold•4.6
- HhalVIPNew York City •32 reviews5.0Dined on 14 Feb 2025Never a bad meal, always wonderful service with delicious food…More infoNoah'sPrice: Expensive• Tapas / Small Plates• Greenport•4.7
Discover best American restaurants in Shelter Island
Discover the essence of American dining on Shelter Island, Suffolk, New York State, where a selection of restaurants offers a delightful exploration of local flavors and culinary innovations. Shelter Island's dining scene thrills with its emphasis on locally-sourced ingredients, reflecting the area's rich agricultural heritage and maritime resources. Each restaurant captures the essence of American cuisine, presenting a range of dishes from classic comfort foods to sophisticated gourmet offerings. The atmosphere in these eateries varies from the cozy and intimate to the elegantly casual, ensuring a setting that complements any dining experience. Not only is the food a highlight, but the service is also noted for its attentiveness and warmth, enhancing the overall dining pleasure. As Shelter Island is a coveted destination, making reservations is advisable to secure a spot in these sought-after establishments. Whether you're a local or a visitor, these restaurants promise an unforgettable taste of American culinary excellence right in the heart of Suffolk.