Best Contemporary Mexican Restaurants in Prospect Lefferts Gardens

Price

££
£££
££££

Regions

BrooklynManhattanQueens

Areas

BushwickCarroll GardensEast HarlemGreenwich VillageHell's KitchenHudson Yards

Top Rated

CharmingDog-friendlyGood for business mealsGood for groupsGood for special occasionsGreat for brunch

Dining Options

All dining options

Delivery only

Takeaway only

Seating options

BarStandardHigh TopOutdoor

Accessibility

Gender-neutral toiletWheelchair access

19 restaurants available nearby

1. Fonda - Brooklyn

4.8

Exceptional(1041)

££££Price: Expensive

• Contemporary mexican • Park Slope

Booked 9 times today

Contemporary, authentic Mexican cuisine in a relaxing, fun atmosphere. Incredible margaritas and "best of its kind" Mexican Home Cooking.Outdoor Heating Patio

A photo of Chela Modern Mexican restaurant

2. Chela Modern Mexican

4.7

Exceptional(454)

££££Price: Expensive

• Contemporary mexican • Park Slope

Booked 13 times today

Chela Modern Mexican, nestled in the vibrant Park Slope neighborhood of Brooklyn, offers an unforgettable Contemporary Mexican dining experience. With a menu that beautifully balances traditional Mexican dishes and innovative creations, diners are treated to "finger-licking good" birria and chicken tacos, as well as the "best chilaquiles in town." The restaurant's authenticity shines through in its delicious and fresh offerings, complemented by an impressive selection of 50 types of tequilas and mezcals. Guests rave about the "fantastic" service and cozy atmosphere, making it a perfect spot for both intimate date nights and lively group gatherings. Chela promises a delightful culinary journey with every visit.

3. Añejo Tribeca

4.6

Exceptional(1200)

££££Price: Expensive

• Contemporary mexican • TriBeCa

Booked 22 times today

At Añejo Tribeca, the Tapas/Small Plates cuisine is a vibrant celebration of authentic Mexican flavors, meticulously crafted by chef Ricardo Camacho. Diners rave about the "delicious al fresco dining" and the "superb" ambiance that complements the artistic, rustic setting. Standout dishes like cauliflower tacos and pork belly tostadas are frequently highlighted in reviews as "some of the best Mexican food" in the city. Regular patrons appreciate the "amazing experience" and the attentive service that makes each visit memorable. Whether you're enjoying a casual brunch or a lively dinner, Añejo's small plates promise a culinary journey that's both delightful and distinctive.

4. Xolo

4.7

Exceptional(73)

££££Price: Expensive

• Contemporary mexican • Williamsburg

Booked 6 times today

Contemporary Mexican cuisine with a dash of tradition for good measure–Xolo is located steps away from the Williamsburg waterfront with stunning dining room views of the Williamsburg Bridge. The space is fun yet sophisticated, offering a range of dishes, from small Mexican bar snacks to carefully crafted entrees. Sip on refreshing margaritas or try our creative signature cocktails. Make sure to also check out our beautifully decorated downstairs lounge, Bar Milagro!

5. Bar San Miguel

4.7

Exceptional(8)

££££Price: Expensive

• Contemporary mexican • Carroll Gardens

Booked 3 times today

Located in Carroll Gardens, Bar San Miguel is a delightful and relaxed restaurant that serves authentic Mexican dishes and fantastic drinks. The restaurant is inspired by the historic town of San Miguel de Allende located in the hills of Mexico. Bar San Miguel provides a rustic cozy atmosphere with an amazing back patio to serve patrons quality Mexican dishes, craft tequila, margaritas and mezcal cocktails. Does Bar San Miguel offer the best Mexican dishes in New York City? Well, no. Simply because there is no such thing. However, they do have a fantastic selection of tacos and enchiladas that will more than delight your palate. More so if you are chasing them with tequila drinks with a hint of jalapeno. The customer service at Bar San Miguel is excellent and the staff is very friendly. Ultimately, the restaurant gives you the vibe of a neighborhood restaurant —one where you might meet up with some friends for dinner, have some drinks, and perhaps ponder over your investment strategy.

6. Bar Basic

4.5

Awesome(15)

££££Price: Moderate

• Contemporary mexican • Park Slope

Booked 2 times today

Bar Basic is a restaurant in Brooklyn, New York that serves American cuisine. The restaurant has a warm and welcoming atmosphere, with a beautifully appointed dining room that provides an intimate setting for lunch or dinner. The menu features elevated favorites from the kitchen, as well as cocktails made with specially curated ingredients. Bar Basic is a great place to celebrate a special occasion or just enjoy a delicious meal with friends and family.

7. Sobre Masa

new

5.0

Exceptional(1)

££££Price: Expensive

• Contemporary mexican • Bushwick

Booked 9 times today

Sobre Masa is a contemporary Mexican restaurant located in Bushwick, Brooklyn. Our menu is designed to be enjoyed family-style, highlighting authentic and modern Mexican cuisine.Our kitchen is centered around housemade nixtamal and tortillas, crafted daily from heirloom corn sourced directly from small farms across Mexico.Our beverage program features a thoughtful selection of Mexican spirits from across the country, alongside riffs on classic cocktails.The kitchen is led by Oaxacan Chef Zack Wangeman, whose cooking is rooted in nostalgia, seasonality, and respect for heirloom ingredients—showcasing the depth of Mexican cuisine beyond the plate.

A photo of Toloache - Upper East Side restaurant

8. Toloache - Upper East Side

4.8

Exceptional(1643)

££££Price: Expensive

• Contemporary mexican • Upper East Side

Booked 32 times today

Toloache - Upper East Side is a true gem for contemporary Mexican cuisine, where "authenticity meets creativity" in the heart of New York. Chef-owner Julian Medina's culinary prowess shines through every dish, offering a vibrant fusion of traditional and modern flavors. The menu, enriched with seasonal ingredients and over a dozen types of chilies, guarantees a delightful gastronomic experience. Diners rave about the "tacos, enchiladas, and guacamole" which are consistently delicious, while the extensive tequila list complements the flavors perfectly. The restaurant's warm hospitality and charming Mexican décor transport guests to a world of culinary magic, making every visit memorable.

9. Toloache-Midtown

4.7

Exceptional(7676)

££££Price: Moderate

• Contemporary mexican • Theater District

Booked 50 times today

Toloache-Midtown offers a mesmerizing experience of Contemporary Mexican cuisine right in the heart of New York's Theater District. Chef-owner Julian Medina's bistro is celebrated for its creative dishes that artfully blend seasonal and natural ingredients, highlighted by a dazzling array of over a dozen types of chilies. Standout reviews describe the food as "delicious, creative, high-end Mexican" and praise the "authentic and delicious Mexican cuisine." Diners rave about the expertly prepared guacamole and ceviche, as well as the flavorful tacos and succulent birria. With a vibrant atmosphere and exceptional service, Toloache-Midtown is a must-visit for Mexican food enthusiasts.

A photo of Wicked Willy's Bar & Grill restaurant

10. Wicked Willy's Bar & Grill

4.6

Exceptional(12)

££££Price: Moderate

• Contemporary mexican • Greenwich Village

Booked 8 times today

Wicked Willy’s is the ultimate Greenwich Village stop! Escape into a Caribbean oasis of pirates, palm trees, and fun. You name it, Wicked Willy’s has it. Beer Pong, Live Music, Sports Games, karaoke, live DJ, and daily drink specials that can’t be matched! Whether your looking to enjoy happy hour while watching your favorite sports team on one of our 15 HD TV’s or our big screen, relax in our front and back lounges, or take a picture with our famous Wicked Willy’s Bike our motto remains the same: Time Flies When Your Having Rum!

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

See what locals rave about

From verified diners like you

A
Atma
New York City •4 reviews
5.0
Dined on 2 Mar 2025
Super amazing authentic gourmet Mexican food, hard to find in the United States. The Chef has it going on.
More info
Sobre MasaPrice: Expensive• Mexican• Bushwick
•
5
B
Bamlak
New York City •1 review
4.0
Dined on 23 Feb 2025
Long waits for service after being seated. They seemed short-staffed. Food was just ok
More info
XoloPrice: Expensive• Contemporary Mexican• Williamsburg
•
4.7
OT
OpenTable Diner
New York City •1 review
5.0
Dined on 15 Feb 2025
Went for Valentine’s Day dinner. Not too crowded and the music and ambiance were great. Drinks and food were excellent and our server was friendly and attentive!
More info
Chela Modern MexicanPrice: Expensive• Mexican• Park Slope
•
4.7
JG
JerseyGirl
Atlantic City / South Jersey Shore •4 reviews
5.0
Dined on 4 Jan 2020
Small cozy space with innovative and delicious Tex/Mex menu. Service was very good. Reservations may be needed depending upon day and time. Highly reccomended
More info
Bar BasicPrice: Moderate• American• Park Slope
•
4.5

Explore OpenTable

Area
Cuisine nearby
Contemporary mexican cuisine

Prospect Lefferts Gardens

Contemporary mexican

Hudson Yards
Elmhurst
Park Slope
Long Island City
Lower East Side
Midtown West
Battery Park City
Midtown East
Boerum Hill
Woodhaven
Upper West Side
Astoria
Corona
Whitestone
West Village
Turtle Bay
Carnegie Hill
Woodside
Flushing
Harlem