Diners' Choice: Italian restaurants in Caribbean

OpenTable

Updated 05 December 2024

Looking for restaurants with the best overall Italian cuisine in Caribbean? You’re in the right place. Each month OpenTable analyses more than 400,000 new diner reviews. We sort the results by category to help you discover new favourites. It's a great partnership: you reserve, eat, and review. We listen...and deliver the results for all to benefit. Enjoy!

Asia de Lima

4.9

4.9 (60)

$30 and under

Italian

Condado

About the restaurant

We have a varied menu of pizza and pasta with Asian and Peruvian flavors. We also have traditional flavors and cocktails in a family atmosphere.

Top review

Jonathan

Dined on 24 Nov 2024

Absolutely delicious! Such a wonderful culinary experience with wonderful atmosphere and kind staff. Cannot recommend enough!

Grappa

4.8

4.8 (9)

$31 to $50

Italian

Dorado

About the restaurant

Quaint local eatery, serving refined Italian cuisine.

Top review

Jane

Dined 5 days ago

An absolutely wonderful experience. We would go again!

Nonna Cucina Rustica

4.8

4.8 (628)

$30 and under

Italian

San Juan

About the restaurant

A unique Italian gastronomic experience awaits you at Nonna, where we honor the dedication, care and love that Italian grandmothers put into each plate.

Nonna provides a unique atmosphere, full of history where you can savor Italian classic dishes made from scratch with fresh vegetables, assorted cheeses, unfiltered extra virgin olive oil and fresh handmade pasta made daily.

The menu includes a selection of dishes ranging from antipasti, soups and pasta with a variety of meats and seafood. The pizzas are made with carefully selected ingredients including Caputo flour from Naples, Italy, extra virgin olive oil unfiltered and fresh mozzarella.

"La Nonna” was the precursor of this Italian cuisine where they used the best ingredients while preparing everything from scratch. It is a throwback to the traditional and rustic cuisine. We try to respect these methods and recipes from the past while integrating cutting-edge techniques.

Top review

Lianne

Dined on 6 Dec 2024

This restaurant is so homey, the food is so delicious and fresh and the staff is a joy. Specially Jan, she helped us in the selection of our dishes… she knows the entire menu and recommended the best plates for each person.

Discover more

Popular dish

Ravioli d'Anatra

Popular dish

Ravioli Ricotta & Goat Cheese

Popular dish

Lasagna del Giorno

Ristorante Pappagallo

4.9

4.9 (418)

$31 to $50

Italian

West Bay

About the restaurant

Whatever the occasion, Pappagallo provides the perfect setting to satisfy all your senses. From the moment you step onto the wooden bridge leading to the entrance you are transported into another world. We offer several dining options, indoors and out, but it is the spectacular details of our 30-foot Cayman-style, Silver Thatch roof that is truly breathtaking! The menu changes regularly under the inspired guardianship of Chef Alex Menegon who demands freshness of food as an absolute priority. The contemporary cuisine at Pappagallo is typified by its simplicity and freshness. The kitchen is a hive of activity as fresh pastas and breads are made daily. Chef Alex uses as much locally caught seafood as is available and only the best of USDA Certified meats are offered. Fresh vegetables and fruits are featured in all dishes and, for the sweets-lover, a dessert menu starring only handcrafted desserts. So sit back, relax and enjoy one of the best dining experiences in Grand Cayman!

Top review

karlVIP

Dined 7 days ago

Wow, this place was exceptional in every way. We will definitely go back on future visits

Tavola Condado Trattoria Local

4.7

4.7 (124)

$30 and under

Italian

San Juan

About the restaurant

Tavola trattoria is a very cozy place in the heart of Condado, Puerto Rico with delicious homemade Italian dishes. Our menu included artisan pizzettas, fresh seafood, risottos and homemade pasta everyday with fresh ingredients.
You need to try our famous appetizers like Carpaccio di Manzo, eggplant involtini, truffle mac & cheese, Manchego croquettes and fry burrata. Tavola also have our customers favorites like the half boneless chicken al Forno and the carbonara pasta. Don't forget to try the creme brulé and the chocolate cake.

Top review

NataliaVIP

Dined 5 days ago

Excellent service and food. Austin took care of your table perfectly and the food was delicious. Thank you!

The Little Venice

4.8

4.8 (190)

$31 to $50

Italian

Hamilton

About the restaurant

Little Venice is Bermuda’s first and most famous Italian restaurant, located on Bermudiana Road in the City of Hamilton.
Celebrating almost 50 years of fabulous service, fine food and meticulously prepared classic and contemporary regional Italian specialties ranging from its significant ties to the Campania region as well as Lombardia, Veneto and Liguria with famous dishes such as the signature Cacio e Pepe personally prepared at your table.

The restaurant has a vibrant and welcoming atmosphere with various seating areas, providing a cozy table for two or a table front and centre to be seen by the surrounding ‘Wall Street of Bermuda’ clientele. The outside terrazzo with its new and expanded al fresco area is the heart of Hamilton’s outdoor dining, creating additional excitement to an already dynamic scene.

Top review

Robert James

Dined on 4 Dec 2024

Without a doubt, this is the best Italian Restaurant in Bermuda. Don’t miss it.

Pesce Italian

4.9

4.9 (1298)

$30 and under

Italian

St. Thomas

About the restaurant

Fresh Seafood ~ Homemade Pasta ~ Local Ingredients
Step outside of St Thomas and into Tuscany when you dine at PESCE iTALiAN. Offering the best in fresh In-House made Pasta, as it is made daily at our live action pasta station! The PESCE iTALiAN menu reflects the culinary sensibilities of the Italian people: rustic yet sophisticated.
Creative blends of herbs and spices, with a fusion of fresh ingredients and local seafood adds a contemporary twist to the elements of creating phenomenal Italian cuisine that has proudly served the East End of St Thomas for over a decade. Of course, another building block in creating the perfect experience is the friendly, dedicated staff that is knowledgeable of the beautiful relationship between food and wine – served with the warmth and hospitality of the Italian people. Our Wine Spectators Award Winning List is sure to offer many options to pair the perfect wine with any of the Italian delicacies on menu.

Top review

Tom

Dined 5 days ago

All aspects were outstanding, the service, appetizers, drinks, entrees, etc. Outstanding !

Discover more

Popular dish

Spaghetti Carbonara

Popular dish

Spaghetti & Meatballs

Popular dish

Fettuccine Alfredo

Azzurro at Silversands Beach House

4.8

4.8 (17)

$50 and over

Italian

Saint George's

About the restaurant

FINE BEACHFRONT DINING
Welcome to Azzurro—a Grenada dining experience that's unlike any other. Indulge in fresh, Italian-inspired cuisine as you admire panoramic views of the beach, the sand powder-soft beneath your feet. Pasta dishes are handmade in-house, with local seafood and premium cuts of meat plated to perfection.

Top review

SarahVIP

Dined on 13 Dec 2024

The setting is lovely and the service is very good, particularly for Grenada. But the prices are very high and the food, while beautifully presented, doesn’t justify the cost. I had an adequate, if rather dry and bland, red snapper fillet that was over $40 USD! Nothing on the plate was anything other than okay. If I want to drop that kind of money again, there are better places in Grenada where at least I feel like the food is special enough to somewhat justify the cost.

Mogano by Giorgio Locatelli

4.8

4.8 (529)

$50 and over

Italian

Bahamas

About the restaurant

Under the dappled shade of the many native Mahogany trees of which the name originates, Mogano by Giorgio Locatelli brings the best of Italian cuisine to life in The Bahamas, with a range of exquisite pasta dishes and seasonal mains, all made with the freshest ingredients.

The Island House is excited to partner with Italian Michelin Star Chef Giorgio Locatelli to provide you with a world class culinary experience, unparalleled to anything The Bahamas has seen before, and in this case the first partnership ever in the western hemisphere. Mogano by Giorgio Locatelli offers spacious seating with a warm ambience that manages to combine a sense of privacy with the atmosphere of family dining.

**During the holiday season, reservations for 6 or more must be made directly with the restaurant.

Top review

Elaine

Dined 3 days ago

Every thing is great except the restaurant can be very noisy when full or with misbehaving children. The children are the parents responsibility to behave and keep noise level to minimum. The restaurant ambience is beautiful but could use some fabric strategically place to absorb the noise.

Discover more

Popular dish

Spaghetti Vongole

Italy in the World

4.7

4.7 (208)

$31 to $50

Italian

Oranjestad

About the restaurant

We are a small Italian restaurant that offers a wide variety of typical dishes and the best Italian wines, made in the most traditional way.
Homemade pasta, with various types of fillings; or the most traditional pasta such as bolognese, amatricciana, frutti di mare, putanesca, genovesa, gnocchi meat sauce, carbonara, lasagna, frutti di mare.
Meats such as Osso Bucco, Brasato stew, scalopina in wine, braciola, chicken parmiggiana and seafood dishes like Ciopino
All made to order while you enjoy getting to know our house....the oldest house in Oranjestad, the capital of Aruba

Top review

Jean-Noël

Dined on 11 Dec 2024

Very nice typical house and the best Italian restaurant in Aruba! The foods are very good and service excellent. We ate our diner on the outdoor terrace but inside the old house is very typical. I recommend this restaurant! Johny from Canada

Explore Diners' Choice best of Caribbean

Explore more Diners' Choice lists